{
  "format": "vercy-enterprise-profile-candidate/v1",
  "contourId": "EM-DAT-07",
  "name": "Enterprise Analytical Study, Finding and Recommendation Binding",
  "decision": "PROFILE",
  "newRuntimeId": false,
  "bases": ["WM-ACT-036", "WM-ACT-034", "WM-KNW-007", "WM-KNW-010", "WM-ACT-024", "WM-REC-002"],
  "constraints": [
    "WM-ACT-036 owns analytical-study identity, question, protocol, population, sampling, method application, estimates and limitations.",
    "WM-ACT-034 contributes assessment mechanics through a non-mastership relation; it is neither a specialization parent nor an identity source for Analytical Study.",
    "Every WM-KNW-007 claim in this profile carries independent closed discriminators claimMood and claimKind. Finding means claimMood=assertoric; Recommendation means claimMood=deontic. This profile creates no Recommendation type or identifier.",
    "claimKind is descriptive, associational or causal. A causal claim is admissible only when measurand, comparator, design, competing-explanation analysis and sampling-frame-bias discharge are all recorded.",
    "A finding claimKind must be permitted by the pinned Analysis Method revision and must independently satisfy the study-level claim gate; neither condition alone is sufficient.",
    "Every finding specification pins study, method revision, sample version and data version; unresolved identities make the pin pending rather than empty or defaulted.",
    "Every method deviation is classified within-applicability or out-of-applicability. An out-of-applicability deviation retains the pin but removes method warrant for affected causal outputs, which become associational or withdrawn.",
    "Competing interpretations remain conflict-linked claims. Ranking, preference or confidence never eliminates a rival. An explicit WM-KNW-007 defeater claim with its own mood, kind and pins marks a rival defeated and retained.",
    "A recommendation's deontic mood confers no authority, permission, competence, disposition or effect. WM-KNW-010 owns decision rationale and WM-ACT-024 owns the authorized occurrence.",
    "A recommendation may have zero or more decisions; decision content may exist without an antecedent recommendation. Rejection leaves the recommendation unchanged and resolvable.",
    "A WM-REC-002 report pins the exact study and finding versions it renders and introduces no conclusion absent from those findings.",
    "Changing any finding pin creates a retained superseding successor; the predecessor and reports pinned to it remain immutable."
  ],
  "outOfScope": ["reviewer, approver and authorizing-party identity", "allocation of Analysis Method, sample or dataset identity", "relation-vocabulary registration"],
  "holds": [
    "Analysis Method remains identifier-unassigned.",
    "Sample and dataset identity have no allocated basis in this profile, so the four-part finding pin is specified but not executable.",
    "Conflict-link, defeater, successor and assessment-mechanics relation contracts remain unregistered.",
    "Recommendation is only a mood-discriminated WM-KNW-007 claim here; any future Recommendation specialization requires separate allocation and audit.",
    "WM-REC-002 and the other bases are not canonically publishable.",
    "Source/profile pins and crosswalks remain incomplete.",
    "All fixtures are specified but not executed."
  ]
}