{
  "format": "vercy-enterprise-profile-candidate/v1",
  "contourId": "EM-LEG-05",
  "name": "Enterprise Legal Case, Claim and Outcome Binding",
  "decision": "PROFILE",
  "newRuntimeId": false,
  "bases": [
    "WM-POL-009",
    "WM-KNW-007",
    "WM-KNW-008",
    "WM-KNW-010",
    "WM-ECO-006",
    "WM-ECO-018"
  ],
  "constraints": [
    "WM-POL-009 owns one docket-qualified proceeding, forum assignment, roles, events, schedules, hearings, rulings, finality and closure.",
    "Procedural claims, counterclaims, defenses and proceeding events remain case-owned assertions.",
    "Party allegations profile WM-KNW-007 while adjudicated findings and legal conclusions remain authority-owned.",
    "Filing content, evidence custody and judgment content remain external masters even when the case records docket use.",
    "Case Outcome is an as-of projection over judgment identity, disposition, finality and remedy references; it has no identity, no lifecycle and no mastership, and it never instantiates a remedy obligation.",
    "Provisioning, recognition, derecognition and payment never follow from a claimed or judgment amount; each requires its own authorized accounting act with initiation separated from authorization, and no financial-statement draft subscribes to claim amounts.",
    "No constraint of this profile may be evaluated against a blockedBases target; references to filing, evidence and judgment masters are recorded as deferred, never bound.",
    "An appellate or enforcement docket may be recorded as a separate WM-POL-009 proceeding instance for docket mechanics only; this profile declares no appellate, recognition or enforcement coverage and no appeal subtype of the first-instance profile.",
    "An appeal is a successor proceeding with its own identity and never replaces, renumbers or absorbs the first-instance proceeding."
  ],
  "holds": [
    "Dispute / Matter remains identifier-unassigned.",
    "Required child specifications and enforcement references are incomplete.",
    "Independent Grok review is reconciled and the frozen audit is complete; base drafts remain non-canonical single- or dual-provider drafts with external review waived or absent."
  ],
  "blockedBases": [
    {
      "target": "WM-POL-019",
      "expectedScope": "filing identity and content",
      "status": "reserved-incomplete",
      "profileBinding": "none",
      "parentDeclaredRequiredChild": true
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-POL-020",
      "expectedScope": "evidence identity, custody, integrity",
      "status": "reserved-incomplete",
      "profileBinding": "none",
      "parentDeclaredRequiredChild": true
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-POL-021",
      "expectedScope": "judgment or award identity, text, composition, reasons, corrections",
      "status": "reserved-incomplete",
      "profileBinding": "none",
      "parentDeclaredRequiredChild": true
    }
  ],
  "compositionHold": {
    "state": "unsatisfiable",
    "reason": "WM-POL-009 declares WM-POL-019/020/021 as CHILD required:true while all three lack complete specifications",
    "resolution": "registry adjudication",
    "promotionForbidden": true
  },
  "relationContradictions": [
    {
      "target": "WM-POL-022",
      "registryName": "Sanction / Sentence",
      "declaredParent": "WM-POL-021",
      "conflictsWith": "Appeal / Review expectation",
      "effect": "not a base, not a reference, not an appeal identifier",
      "resolution": "registry adjudication"
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-KNW-010",
      "conflict": "CHILD + EXTEND + ALIGN to WM-KNW-007",
      "ledgerParent": "absent",
      "resolution": "registry adjudication",
      "profileUse": "rationale structure only"
    }
  ],
  "danglingReferences": [
    {
      "target": "WM-POL-023",
      "referencedBy": "WM-POL-021",
      "role": "enforcement",
      "registryState": "absent-from-reservations",
      "action": "record-only",
      "reservationForbidden": true,
      "baseBindingForbidden": true
    }
  ],
  "projections": {
    "CaseOutcome": {
      "kind": "projection",
      "identity": "none",
      "lifecycle": "none",
      "nonAuthoritative": true,
      "required": [
        "asOf",
        "derivedFrom"
      ],
      "derivedFrom": [
        "judgmentRef(blocked: WM-POL-021 incomplete)",
        "finalityAssertionRef(case-owned)",
        "remedyRef(deferred: Remedy Obligation unassigned)"
      ],
      "mastershipForbiddenOver": [
        "judgment text",
        "reasons",
        "finality event",
        "remedy terms"
      ],
      "instantiationForbidden": [
        "RemedyObligation"
      ],
      "persistenceAsRoot": "forbidden"
    }
  },
  "baseProvenance": [
    {
      "target": "WM-POL-009",
      "providers": [
        "Codex"
      ],
      "externalReview": "waived",
      "publishableCanonical": false
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-ECO-018",
      "providers": [
        "Codex"
      ],
      "externalReview": "waived",
      "publishableCanonical": false,
      "selfContradiction": "out-of-scope conflict in a service role per EM-FIN-04"
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-KNW-007",
      "providers": [
        "Claude"
      ],
      "publishableCanonical": false
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-KNW-008",
      "providers": [
        "Claude"
      ],
      "publishableCanonical": false
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-KNW-010",
      "providers": [
        "Claude"
      ],
      "publishableCanonical": false
    },
    {
      "target": "WM-ECO-006",
      "publishableCanonical": false
    }
  ],
  "canonicalPublishable": false,
  "newCatalogueId": false,
  "publicationHold": {
    "state": "held",
    "installabilityClaimed": false,
    "publicationReadinessClaimed": false,
    "canonicalCompletenessClaimed": false,
    "reason": "all bases publishableCanonical=false; three required child specifications incomplete"
  },
  "outOfProfileScope": [
    "Appeal / Review record: route, grounds, deadline, stay, effect on finality — identifier-unassigned gap",
    "Enforcement / Recognition Case — identifier-unassigned gap",
    "Remedy Obligation — identifier-unassigned gap",
    "filing content and identity",
    "evidence identity, custody and integrity",
    "judgment or award content",
    "remedy execution and satisfaction",
    "financial provision and confirmed debt identity"
  ]
}