# Exact unsent Grok prompt — EM-LND-07

Independent enterprise metamodel review. Do not browse, invent identifiers or claim standards conformance.

EM-LND-07 covers OfferingLandscape and OfferingPortfolioScope but has no target model IDs. Product Catalogue and Offering Catalogue are unallocated candidates; WM-ACT-004 Service Definition has no complete publication spec. Available adjacent masters cover offer/quote, order, subscription, contract/obligation, customer relationship and observations.

Assess this proposal: Offering Portfolio Scope is a versioned governance/filter profile on the future Offering Catalogue; Offering Landscape is a non-authoritative projection; neither gets business identity. Keep Product, Service, Offering, Quote and Entitlement distinct. Membership derives from market/channel/availability/policy predicates. Comparison declares basis, class-specific justified criteria and comparability verdict. Internal services record typed non-revenue value rather than treating zero revenue as zero value. Duplicate-outcome claims require semantic, consumer, entitlement and substitution evidence. Retirement never cancels quotes, orders, subscriptions, contracts, obligations or entitlements by inference and must record support, retention, successor/migration or no-successor.

Test two commercial products and one internal service under different justified criteria. Return <=900 words with: Verdict; strongest evidence; strongest counterexample; identity/mastership; portfolio boundary; product/service/offering; comparison; duplicate outcomes; economics/value; retirement/obligations; time/scenario; at least 10 invariants; minimum profile shape; blockers. Explicitly decide whether either candidate requires independent identity.