# EM-ORG-04 provider comparison

Claude and Grok converge on **PROFILE** over `WM-ORG-002`, with no new identifier. Unit identity survives rename and reparenting; type, mandate and placement are profile-local constructs rather than new masters. Both reject an unqualified authored parent, keep axes and scenarios separate, and prevent collaboration bodies from being forced into a tree hierarchy.

Grok sharpened axis cardinality and branch isolation, but it also named neighboring identifiers absent from the frozen dossier. Those references are struck. The reconciled profile expresses the boundary only with constructs present in WM-ORG-002: `bodyMode`, `unitAffiliation`, `affiliationInstrumentRef`, `isAlsoFormalOrganization`, placement edges and reporting lines. Scenario, axis mode and the reified mandate key are explicit proposed deltas, not claimed base behavior.