# EM-ORG-05 provider comparison

Claude and Grok converge on **PROFILE** over `WM-ORG-003` and **REUSE** of `WM-ORG-006`, with no new identifier. Both distinguish team-scoped assignment from governed membership, keep employment and access external, support temporary inter-company teams and standing communities, and refuse roster-derived authority, funding or entitlement.

Grok sharpened inter-company cardinalities, the four independently dated employment/assignment/membership/grant planes, and the owned-versus-referenced WorkingAgreement rule. Claude supplied the stronger identity/lifecycle test, the base containment contradiction and the missing-relation review holds. References to neighboring identifiers not present in the frozen dossier are treated as explanatory only and are not adopted as verified dependencies.