# Independent review request: EM-RSK-01 Risk, Control and Assessment

Review this boundary independently. Proposed: reuse WM-KNW-015 as Risk / Opportunity; restrict WM-XCT-027 to a host-scoped Risk Assessment Context; add one identifier-unassigned Control candidate owning definition, implementation state and lifecycle; profile reserved WM-ACT-034 for control testing/effectiveness after crosswalk; delegate treatment to EM-RSK-02 and reference evidence, appetite and acceptance decisions. Control existence or green policy status never proves effectiveness or closes risk. Estimates are comparable only with matching or explicitly convertible scale, method, criteria, scope and horizon. Test one control linked to three risks where a failed execution changes only an assessment with matching population, period, mechanism and evidence chain. Return <=1000 words: Verdict; identity/mastership; assessment/comparability; control design/execution/effectiveness; residual risk/treatment; shared cause; invariants; scenario; blockers. Challenge whether Control Assessment can safely profile WM-ACT-034. Do not invent identifiers or claim canonical completeness.