{ "format": "vercy-model-allocation-candidate/v1", "contourId": "EM-STR-02", "proposedName": "Outcome and Benefit Boundary Register", "modelId": null, "registryId": null, "allocationState": "unassigned", "allocationBoundaryState": "deferred-two-roots-combined-root-rejected", "decision": "BOUNDARY REGISTER; NO MODEL ALLOCATION", "canonicalPublishable": false, "candidateRevision": 3, "clusterIdentityTest": { "scope": "Non-binding research sketches only; the WM-ACT-029/EM-WRK-03 crosswalk may change identity, lifecycle, ownership and key shape. No aggregate root is asserted.", "perObject": { "Outcome": { "candidateIdentity": [ "outcomeId" ], "mastership": "outcome owner / measurement interpretation authority; unresolved", "lifecycle": [ "hypothesised", "claimed", "observed", "contested", "withdrawn", "superseded" ], "binding": "non-binding-sketch", "transitionSketch": [ "hypothesised->claimed", "claimed->observed", "claimed->contested", "observed->contested", "*->withdrawn", "*->superseded" ] }, "Benefit": { "candidateIdentity": [ "benefitId" ], "mastership": "benefits register or value office; unresolved against WM-ACT-029 and EM-WRK-03", "lifecycle": [ "expected", "forecast", "partially-realised", "realised", "reversed", "closed", "superseded" ], "binding": "non-binding-sketch", "transitionSketch": [ "expected->forecast", "forecast->partially-realised", "forecast->realised", "partially-realised->realised", "realised->reversed", "realised->closed", "reversed->closed", "*->superseded" ] } } }, "boundary": { "owns": [ "research boundary decisions only" ], "references": [ { "target": "WM-KNW-011", "purpose": "Objective, Key Result and Target" }, { "target": "EM-DAT-05", "purpose": "Metric Definition revision" }, { "target": "WM-MAT-008", "purpose": "candidate qualified Observation host under an EM-STR-02 usage rule only; CHILD relation unfrozen and Claude's unassigned-host alternative remains open" }, { "target": "WM-XCT-025", "purpose": "observation mixin usage rule only" }, { "target": "WM-ACT-034", "purpose": "Value Assessment activity" }, { "target": "WM-ACT-029", "purpose": "results-chain and benefit-owner crosswalk" }, { "target": "EM-WRK-03", "purpose": "program, work and deliverable contribution" } ], "excludes": [ "combined Outcome and Benefit aggregate", "metric or observation mastership", "work or deliverable identity", "automatic realization or scalar netting" ] }, "potentialRoots": { "Outcome": { "allocation": "deferred", "identity": "subject plus state-of-interest plus horizon", "owns": [ "state-change assertion", "status and assertion history", "observation citations" ], "binding": "non-binding-sketch", "candidateIdentity": "subject plus state-of-interest plus horizon; subject to crosswalk", "objectiveCardinality": "zero-to-many" }, "Benefit": { "allocation": "deferred", "identity": "beneficiary plus value-kind plus valuation profile plus period", "owns": [ "expected and realized claim history", "polarity", "Benefit-owned Attribution Claims", "residual unattributed contribution" ], "binding": "non-binding-sketch", "candidateIdentity": "beneficiary plus value-kind plus valuation profile plus period; subject to crosswalk", "polarityValues": [ "benefit", "disbenefit" ], "polarityPolicy": "Each polarity is a separately identifiable value record using the same candidate shape; Disbenefit is not a separate model.", "basis": "Outcome reference or explicit counterfactual/assumption reference for either polarity", "attributionClaimRequired": [ "contributorRef", "methodRef", "asOf", "uncertaintyInterval", "evidenceRefs", "adjudicationStatus", "causalLimit" ], "measurementPending": "data-absent-reason only; claim state remains forecast" } }, "invariantRules": [ { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-01", "text": "Objective, Metric Definition, Target, Observation, Outcome, Benefit and Deliverable remain distinct identities or referenced subjects." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-02", "text": "WM-KNW-011 remains the Objective, Key Result and Target master; a Key Result is a measurable-progress role and not a new root." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-03", "text": "Every quantitative target pins an exact Metric Definition revision, unit, operator, baseline period and target period; latest or bare-name references are invalid." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-04", "text": "Metric redefinition never silently rewrites a target; it creates a successor binding with retained prior value and comparability note." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-05", "text": "WM-XCT-025 is used only on qualified WM-MAT-008 observation hosts under an explicit usage rule and is never embedded in goals, assessments, Outcomes or Benefits." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-06", "text": "Observation, deliverable acceptance, planned effect and KR attainment never by themselves prove an Outcome or realised Benefit." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-07", "text": "Outcome and Benefit are separate potential roots with different identity, lifecycle and mastership; this boundary register allocates neither." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-08", "text": "An Outcome asserts a subject state-change and horizon and cites qualified observations without owning measurement facts." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-09", "text": "A Benefit identifies beneficiary, value kind, valuation profile and Outcome or counterfactual basis and is never owned by an Outcome write boundary." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-10", "text": "Attribution Claim is a Benefit-owned revisable assertion and never rewrites Outcome, Observation or contributing work." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-11", "text": "Adjudicated attribution shares for one Benefit and period cannot exceed one; residual unattributed contribution is explicit and permitted." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-12", "text": "Program and constituent projects reference one Benefit identity and never create duplicate realised-Benefit records for the same value and period." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-13", "text": "Benefit and Disbenefit are separately identifiable value records using a polarity code; neither is silently netted into the other." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-14", "text": "Missing or delayed measurement carries an explicit absent reason and remains forecast or measurement-pending; it is never represented as zero or realised." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-15", "text": "Value Assessment pins criteria, valuation profile, method, scale, evidence and uncertainty and may conclude valued, anti-valued, insufficient-evidence or incomparable." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-16", "text": "Net value requires a declared commensuration method and loads related Disbenefits or explicitly declares them out of scope." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-17", "text": "Uncertainty travels with observations, attribution claims and assessment conclusions and is never stripped by aggregation or comparison." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-18", "text": "Superseded Objective bindings, Outcome assertions, Benefit claims and assessment conclusions remain resolvable and are never overwritten or recycled." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-19", "text": "Realisation requires at least one qualified observation with final or amended status whose phenomenon time falls inside the declared realisation window; provisional or out-of-window observations do not license realisation." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-20", "text": "A programme-level attribution claim and its constituent project claims cannot all be adjudicated for the same Benefit and period; the programme either holds the claim with project shares beneath it or holds none." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-21", "text": "Every Attribution Claim carries contributor, method reference, as-of time, uncertainty interval, evidence references, adjudication status and causal limit; share is optional." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-22", "text": "Ordinal, nominal and offset scales refuse scalar conversion even when a method is cited; incompatibility remains explicit." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-23", "text": "WM-XCT-025 comparability advice is non-authoritative; scalar netting is a separately identified Value Assessment with its own method, evidence and uncertainty." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-24", "text": "An Outcome may exist without an Objective and may serve multiple Objectives; forcing a one-to-one Objective containment is invalid." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-25", "text": "The profile adds a Metric Definition revision pin absent from WM-KNW-011 fd-measure-binding and rejects any target whose pinned revision cannot be resolved." }, { "id": "EM-STR-02.BR-26", "text": "Benefit and Disbenefit are separate records using one polarity-bearing candidate shape, not separate models; both require an Outcome or explicit counterfactual basis." } ], "holds": [ "No model or registry identifier is allocated or guessed.", "Outcome and Benefit allocation is deferred pending WM-ACT-029 and EM-WRK-03 ownership crosswalk; all identity/lifecycle/ownership shapes here are non-binding sketches.", "The original combined aggregate is rejected.", "WM-KNW-011 and WM-XCT-025 are non-canonical reviewable drafts under single-provider waiver and publishableCanonical=false.", "Both base relationship contracts are empty, so exclusions are declared but not enforceable.", "No semantic crosswalk has been verified.", "WM-KNW-011 parent WM-ACT-008 containment is contested.", "WM-XCT-025 field-group identity is deferred and its WM-MAT-008 CHILD relation is unfrozen; Claude's unassigned observation-host alternative remains open.", "EM-DAT-05 Metric Definition mastership is unallocated.", "WM-KNW-011 fd-measure-binding lacks the additive revision-pin field required by this profile.", "WM-ACT-034 lacks an approved Value Assessment profile.", "Counterfactual-only Benefit and intended-versus-realised identity remain unresolved.", "Package conversion and live conformance are pending." ], "publicationStatement": "Research boundary register only; not canonically publishable, installable, allocated or verified." }