# EM-WRK-05 provider comparison

Claude and Grok agree that Resource Demand and Resource Pool require independent identity and must remain identifier-unassigned. Capacity Plan profiles WM-ACT-008; AllocationScenario and ResourceAllocation remain contained planning semantics. Grok accepted with four enforceability blockers. The single frozen Claude audit returned REVISE with 25 material artifact defects. Candidate revision 2 closes all 25 without changing the identity decision or allocating identifiers.