{ "disposition": "publish bounded reviewable draft", "decidedAt": "2026-09-21T22:14:48.677290+00:00", "researchAssurance": "reviewable-draft", "contourStatus": "partial", "studies": { "Claude": { "provider": "Claude", "requested_model": "opus", "actual_models": [ "claude-opus-5" ], "mode": "independent-cli-web-research", "status": "complete", "started_at": "2026-09-21T20:08:56.965801+00:00", "seconds": 429.97, "prompt_sha256": "4d89480657420fe54691f87e3409903d55ab176f9594eb15c9aad2be0e29f738", "response_sha256": "29d31e1f6b42eaf086df9c1e55a0812b2b1b57f4c4e37ddd9129aa482709747f", "permission_denials": [], "tool_uses": [ "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebSearch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebSearch", "WebFetch" ] }, "Grok": { "provider": "Grok", "mode": "independent-browser-study", "status": "complete", "observedModelLabel": "Heavy (Тяжёлый)", "backendModelId": "not exposed by browser UI", "promptSubmitted": true, "prompt_sha256": "4d89480657420fe54691f87e3409903d55ab176f9594eb15c9aad2be0e29f738", "promptTransmission": "Exact authored source pasted through the browser; full visible user message and final paragraph verified. Transport byte identity is not asserted.", "conversation": "https://grok.com/c/88aee035-fe33-46a3-a96e-1cbbb1ebf529", "submissionObservedOn": "2026-09-21", "recordedAt": "2026-09-21T20:31:01.465056+00:00", "priorAvailabilityRecord": "grok-enterprise-study.unavailable-20260921.manifest.json", "independence": "Shared public brief only; no Claude output or Codex reconciliation supplied.", "limits": "Grok states parent YAML/HTML was truncated and provided Codex digests were not recomputed; adjacent 005/038/DAT-004/KNW-012 referenced-not-fetched. This is an independent research study, not an implementation audit. Source verification remains separate.", "capturedAt": "2026-09-21T20:35:56.537208+00:00", "response_sha256": "c1a2e3fd26821eb405de83700d05915cd64c2058b6aa61c69499d711b6a14761", "originalArtifact": "grok-enterprise-study.original.docx", "originalArtifact_sha256": "ac67d7e29f62c3506c37fb9e4f7ba51abe63862af277f704b74535e988e4ebf5", "summary_sha256": "9ce00d31db12934bfd138e13ec7e3a2b343dfdebfc6c9f13e22394d4d3930af4", "evidenceFormat": "Original DOCX downloaded by the visible Grok download button; paragraph text mechanically extracted in document order, including table cells. Markdown file is an extraction, not provider-emitted Markdown. Browser final summary captured with Copy answer." } }, "providers": { "Claude": { "status": "complete", "disposition": "ACCEPT WITH LIMITS", "manifest": { "provider": "Claude", "requested_model": "opus", "actual_models": [ "claude-opus-5" ], "mode": "frozen-no-tools-audit", "status": "complete", "started_at": "2026-09-21T22:06:21.419644+00:00", "seconds": 245.92, "prompt_sha256": "f4182be2a11045a7a92678ff7b77e13d387e32ac7f246def5f47cc53a0cd2ead", "response_sha256": "c87ec97abf6a1675b117274fa2a6e4237916dbcf3b264d3b2c63139b04bcf25d", "permission_denials": [], "tool_uses": [] }, "scope": "Frozen full bounded release candidate; static no-tools review, JSON/YAML semantic compact rendering. External toolchain/source bytes not supplied. No provider test execution or hash recomputation claimed." }, "Grok": { "status": "complete", "disposition": "ACCEPT WITH LIMITS", "manifest": { "provider": "Grok", "model_ui": "Heavy", "actual_model_id": "not exposed", "mode": "browser-frozen-no-tools-audit", "status": "complete", "capturedAt": "2026-09-21T22:14:48.5993942Z", "conversation": "https://grok.com/c/4ed4781a-0532-4e5c-9e96-e546199b6e66", "transport": "6 ordered text parts; provider declared all 33 files read without remaining truncation", "prompt_sha256": "f4182be2a11045a7a92678ff7b77e13d387e32ac7f246def5f47cc53a0cd2ead", "response_sha256": "16c0d827734f5b6f91e84a68196dc453543def89107bd172ec3ac2be4ecffa18", "execution": "none; actual response copied through browser UI" }, "scope": "Frozen full bounded release candidate; static no-tools review, JSON/YAML semantic compact rendering. External toolchain/source bytes not supplied. No provider test execution or hash recomputation claimed." } }, "auditSummary": "Claude and Grok completed independent studies, three separate prototype audits each, and three frozen full-package audit rounds. Both final R3 audits accepted the bounded reference with limits; concrete R1/R2 findings were corrected. Executed code/native checks are separate Codex evidence.", "publicationHolds": [ "Host integrations, policy/classification/custody interpretation, transitive active-set governance, production capacity and existing-Dimension migration remain outside the reference.", "All predecessor source/profile holds remain; no whole-parent conformance claimed.", "Preflight record, native envelope and full snapshot independently against the 256 KiB cap: a valid near-limit record may not fit its envelope or snapshot. Native installation is only five operational files; read the complete pinned package and adoption addendum before use. Production capacity and broad EM-XCT-05 remain unimplemented." ], "reviewedFiles": { "acceptance-results.json": "1f6226c93e8ffce8dc8eda896570ccaa9a4f722d5c23b1dfdbb4b524a3dca547", "acceptance.py": "7437d06f70c9631bc2c1b627fbbecf27c0fb539285a0758a93476c01364d4d8e", "adjacent-model-checks.json": "f93ec6cb47d5889da95c58fa58a69940a063cc13d1518ac2dee994ebadd0860b", "adoption-limits.md": "e979948fe669a557be80bbf259cc7ae44b8455a1eb0bcec657e4f265c8003e6c", "agent-guide.md": "293c4013ed1b7bc2bdb5085f866fff566d4507e7d226bfcbb29c0dc9f7743007", "AGENTS.md": "293c4013ed1b7bc2bdb5085f866fff566d4507e7d226bfcbb29c0dc9f7743007", "bindings/native-v3.md": "b9a8718fecb312aa4235457bcdbe7d8fedda3dd454a2ba105080fbb1a2d0ea87", "boundary-decision.md": "65f8ca55641832da69e233872e248eee2246a9ce146a6efdc192ee3eeffc67a7", "composition.yaml": "7a509c5dfb46cdea05fbfd51d52629b49a5ada99d9d928954a06ce7cea30f74d", "crosswalk.json": "07964eec4ae8e74253b86c0d97f0ff5c1c2d92f1e206efca88cdeb3d92d1adf4", "disclosure.py": "c2371aac6c1adfbdd694e7280b2140cae6cd6649aabe3c738e6bd3f925979b17", "disclosure.schema.json": "45b2f2c82b9d9af72b2b462d3e502098fbd5b166bf8bd705947ba12e1e5cc834", "examples/ai.json": "1100097d1526b8c53e5ad51ca75d8d5d0ccb4a59a6afe5a565a532996e799014", "examples/matrix.json": "63199a204156969003e900daea112eba5ff8545f7b21a6ce64e6e2944c04b0a0", "examples/startup.json": "44968621c7d9fbd0256270ff0a95e5a4665b83094a7c574e0ebee89bdf83023d", "invariants.md": "aed31c4ade127ceafd74149988d21ecd329f53aba15a043e0f54dd293055a079", "lifecycle/transitions.md": "e455ac70c2c6a71910763972563200871c9e5757ccf7bf7d78f24234f375fd6b", "mastership-and-rights.yaml": "1e3f52d8e1757d594b5dd2b902e250b988a528d71c05817d3cdb419ae1b95d82", "migration.md": "9081f90ff86cf5e8771d86194c2729f57cdd843bfd0598cb89b2322f10d94293", "model-fields.md": "7b2c06004d84430b82bc79393a05d046fb35968b356dc1ca69f854536c4e0629", "model-spec.md": "98b2e05c2a5443c4527fb5d924a155a6260ed0fb2c37253e9e9c3290dde24879", "publication-manifest.draft": "b860a31d02a00c697e80e3ff28c38f55de58cc1fa1d10cf399560c39034062aa", "README.md": "c13deb9e460be2746464cc9119e38472529b0f724e96495d2d818a4830037240", "requirements.txt": "756cc9e506ae4ee1a6f6c0507088b5cfc0dc8ba350fb2d2d46f1ffa72033adb6", "research.md": "ddc96e493fd410e364eaccbf093dae03732d46e90e95060e8d5ac0e5c680c930", "review.md": "a30e0c2d9849a840c2d0d0f60153a75a1bac62122b66c5e497d67a1019dabed5", "runtime-model.reference.json": "123dd5d1a1c64c0be5fbb0041d05d6e96f161b9d8e77eeb0aea69126eca152a6", "source-verification.json": "be1aaf130043b48239422b935714962cf173945c5154e706a9192ac9e0fe1b49", "spec.json": "208854fbc8c1737ec87acfa54c618b85a9efc1f619e109556d2df8c9267b5017", "test-results.json": "a6645941b1987a847b7d2b38cd367b7c71a4dff879d6293d2e3bdfe181b147b0", "test_disclosure.py": "dd35bec97e0965c739dbb6449069be5dfadfc8e71083ec679bb1cc9ab1dbdf22", "tool-pins.json": "14d54b08bdbe854a00eda39b8643c73473445312bf2ea4902954eaf716bd9ae7", "whole-object-coverage.yaml": "66f81e0647897b1c8ee77a6798bec3a26fe756fdc38c0b8eaf0c9e53a21eba77" }, "candidateFiles": { "acceptance-results.json": "1f6226c93e8ffce8dc8eda896570ccaa9a4f722d5c23b1dfdbb4b524a3dca547", "acceptance.py": "7437d06f70c9631bc2c1b627fbbecf27c0fb539285a0758a93476c01364d4d8e", "adjacent-model-checks.json": "f93ec6cb47d5889da95c58fa58a69940a063cc13d1518ac2dee994ebadd0860b", "adoption-limits.md": "e979948fe669a557be80bbf259cc7ae44b8455a1eb0bcec657e4f265c8003e6c", "agent-guide.md": "293c4013ed1b7bc2bdb5085f866fff566d4507e7d226bfcbb29c0dc9f7743007", "AGENTS.md": "293c4013ed1b7bc2bdb5085f866fff566d4507e7d226bfcbb29c0dc9f7743007", "bindings/native-v3.md": "b9a8718fecb312aa4235457bcdbe7d8fedda3dd454a2ba105080fbb1a2d0ea87", "boundary-decision.md": "65f8ca55641832da69e233872e248eee2246a9ce146a6efdc192ee3eeffc67a7", "composition.yaml": "7a509c5dfb46cdea05fbfd51d52629b49a5ada99d9d928954a06ce7cea30f74d", "crosswalk.json": "07964eec4ae8e74253b86c0d97f0ff5c1c2d92f1e206efca88cdeb3d92d1adf4", "disclosure.py": "c2371aac6c1adfbdd694e7280b2140cae6cd6649aabe3c738e6bd3f925979b17", "disclosure.schema.json": "45b2f2c82b9d9af72b2b462d3e502098fbd5b166bf8bd705947ba12e1e5cc834", "examples/ai.json": "1100097d1526b8c53e5ad51ca75d8d5d0ccb4a59a6afe5a565a532996e799014", "examples/matrix.json": "63199a204156969003e900daea112eba5ff8545f7b21a6ce64e6e2944c04b0a0", "examples/startup.json": "44968621c7d9fbd0256270ff0a95e5a4665b83094a7c574e0ebee89bdf83023d", "invariants.md": "aed31c4ade127ceafd74149988d21ecd329f53aba15a043e0f54dd293055a079", "lifecycle/transitions.md": "e455ac70c2c6a71910763972563200871c9e5757ccf7bf7d78f24234f375fd6b", "mastership-and-rights.yaml": "1e3f52d8e1757d594b5dd2b902e250b988a528d71c05817d3cdb419ae1b95d82", "migration.md": "9081f90ff86cf5e8771d86194c2729f57cdd843bfd0598cb89b2322f10d94293", "model-fields.md": "7b2c06004d84430b82bc79393a05d046fb35968b356dc1ca69f854536c4e0629", "model-spec.md": "98b2e05c2a5443c4527fb5d924a155a6260ed0fb2c37253e9e9c3290dde24879", "post-audit-boundary-results.json": "89899c6f24cf0519d8085f8d44f91bfafb6d7b82bf7e8a82a13ad6d1814a2a89", "publication-addendum.md": "c427a84a56b841649de06fc024923c707d578844b1a9cc2f0b8cf7379bbd2043", "publication-manifest.draft": "b860a31d02a00c697e80e3ff28c38f55de58cc1fa1d10cf399560c39034062aa", "README.md": "c13deb9e460be2746464cc9119e38472529b0f724e96495d2d818a4830037240", "requirements.txt": "756cc9e506ae4ee1a6f6c0507088b5cfc0dc8ba350fb2d2d46f1ffa72033adb6", "research.md": "ddc96e493fd410e364eaccbf093dae03732d46e90e95060e8d5ac0e5c680c930", "review.md": "a30e0c2d9849a840c2d0d0f60153a75a1bac62122b66c5e497d67a1019dabed5", "runtime-model.reference.json": "123dd5d1a1c64c0be5fbb0041d05d6e96f161b9d8e77eeb0aea69126eca152a6", "source-verification.json": "be1aaf130043b48239422b935714962cf173945c5154e706a9192ac9e0fe1b49", "spec.json": "208854fbc8c1737ec87acfa54c618b85a9efc1f619e109556d2df8c9267b5017", "test-results.json": "a6645941b1987a847b7d2b38cd367b7c71a4dff879d6293d2e3bdfe181b147b0", "test_disclosure.py": "dd35bec97e0965c739dbb6449069be5dfadfc8e71083ec679bb1cc9ab1dbdf22", "tool-pins.json": "14d54b08bdbe854a00eda39b8643c73473445312bf2ea4902954eaf716bd9ae7", "whole-object-coverage.yaml": "66f81e0647897b1c8ee77a6798bec3a26fe756fdc38c0b8eaf0c9e53a21eba77" }, "scopeNotes": "33 files reviewed fully in final R3. JSON/YAML compact rendering preserves parsed values. review.json, publication-addendum.md and post-audit-boundary-results.json are explicit post-audit Codex additions, not provider-reviewed files. The boundary supplement reproduces a fails-closed limit in unchanged code; it does not claim a capacity fix.", "adoptionNotice": "Preflight record, native envelope and full snapshot independently against the 256 KiB cap: a valid near-limit record may not fit its envelope or snapshot. Native installation is only five operational files; read the complete pinned package and adoption addendum before use. Production capacity and broad EM-XCT-05 remain unimplemented." }