{ "disposition": "publish bounded reviewable draft", "researchAssurance": "reviewable-draft", "contourStatus": "partial", "decidedAt": "2026-09-21T23:29:23.720781+00:00", "studies": { "Claude": { "provider": "Claude", "requested_model": "opus", "actual_models": [ "claude-opus-5" ], "mode": "independent-cli-web-research", "status": "complete", "started_at": "2026-09-21T22:27:16.990425+00:00", "seconds": 451.88, "prompt_sha256": "d01035159a8150286b1fb4fe461c3b8b8813460c5997763172881bc8dd7744dc", "response_sha256": "bf1e79827e72ebcda978857b1696e42fd42c56f6353cfc5def966be4c6669f48", "permission_denials": [], "tool_uses": [ "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch" ] }, "Grok": { "provider": "Grok", "mode": "independent-browser-web-research", "status": "complete", "ui_mode": "Heavy", "actual_model": "not exposed by browser UI", "conversation_url": "https://grok.com/c/5d894020-0300-4df2-9c73-6b5eca2484da", "captured_at": "2026-09-21T22:37:12.677541+00:00", "prompt_sha256": "d01035159a8150286b1fb4fe461c3b8b8813460c5997763172881bc8dd7744dc", "response_sha256": "93a1801949cb0d22a53995a8a7dc354f9a574ac18063c9a7c4859a272a7aef9f", "evidence_format": "verbatim browser Copy answer Markdown; not schema-validated provider JSON", "source_limits": "Provider reports summarized web extracts; underlying tool calls, hash verification, model identity and teammate attributions were not independently observed." } }, "providers": { "Claude": { "status": "complete", "disposition": "ACCEPT WITH LIMITS", "manifest": { "provider": "Claude", "requested_model": "opus", "actual_models": [ "claude-opus-5" ], "mode": "frozen-no-tools-audit", "status": "complete", "started_at": "2026-09-21T23:21:45.869716+00:00", "seconds": 303.42, "prompt_sha256": "d9804a4d1cbbce674c3e6002204b511e8e847530359de576fcba33e7e6670d5c", "response_sha256": "02fe73b223680598d91df5ffa2f676dc92d2010b4ca63ec465f3aea6b4c62a4c", "permission_denials": [], "tool_uses": [] }, "scope": "Full frozen candidate supplied. Static no-tools audit; JSON/YAML compact-rendered. External sources, toolchain bytes, tests and hashes not independently executed/verified by providers." }, "Grok": { "status": "complete", "disposition": "ACCEPT WITH LIMITS", "manifest": { "provider": "Grok", "ui_mode": "Heavy", "actual_model": "not exposed by UI", "mode": "frozen-no-tools-browser-audit", "status": "complete", "captured_at": "2026-09-21T23:29:23.650442+00:00", "conversation_url": "https://grok.com/c/2e9d192f-9e5a-4a9a-a83b-5ea4246a33c8?rid=7dbd8fd2-1af3-40d1-bd52-e0ac44c062d0", "prompt_sha256": "d9804a4d1cbbce674c3e6002204b511e8e847530359de576fcba33e7e6670d5c", "response_sha256": "0a1cab6a644263b6b28f58bc02ea4ad043be31f2a1f2afc6f7e3e34aa02e7071", "editor_snapshot_sha256": "803463a8f58d22a2508c9dab052abcd06c382e9b4626d13c36cddc5e35c22563", "input_note": "Complete prompt pasted as plain text in <=6000-character chunks; all nonblank lines including indentation verified equal after CRLF normalization. Browser adds blank paragraphs. No provider execution or independent byte verification claimed." }, "scope": "Full frozen candidate supplied. Static no-tools audit; JSON/YAML compact-rendered. External sources, toolchain bytes, tests and hashes not independently executed/verified by providers." } }, "auditSummary": "Actual Claude and Grok independent studies plus four separate frozen full-package no-tools audit rounds. Both final R4 audits accept the bounded original monetary receipt with limits. Claude R4 M1/M2 documentation-sufficiency findings are carried explicitly in a visible publication addendum. Code and native fixture executions are separate Codex evidence.", "adoptionNotice": "Required before use: read publication-addendum.md and final-review-limits.md in addition to the audited agent reading list. This list alone is incomplete (Claude R4 M1). monetary.py 0.1.0 on the tested Python runtime is the only defined verifier; cross-language digest verification is unsupported (M2). Genesis checks do not establish current access. The reference has a 256-receipt lifetime cap per Dimension, enforceable only with complete host-supplied history.", "publicationHolds": [ "Claude R4 M1: agent reading list is incomplete; mandatory publication addendum and residual-limits document must be read separately.", "Claude R4 M2: Python reference is the only defined verifier; cross-language digest encoding contract and vectors are absent.", "Opaque host-admitted source/currency/policy/issuer assertions require actual host resolution, authority and permissions.", "256-input and 256-register bounds are not enterprise storage scale; complete history, retention, current selection, CAS and migration remain host work.", "Only exact same-context money summation and explicit quantization ship. Broader EM-XCT-06 remains unfinished.", "Native install is five operational assets; full pinned package documentation and explicit companion calls are required." ], "reviewedFiles": { "acceptance-results.json": "dc3b625c41d6a9ac34e5392c6fa518e232e013f35d3891ca5fbf04e20b55cbce", "acceptance.py": "1bbf5d55cf91f1a13bc2aa366d7eaf021efca61117195bef5335919cc77df7e5", "adoption-limits.md": "e143c64f983dcdbb879323aef44637b9536a56647c98dbceb6a875904bdf93cd", "agent-guide.md": "b0869db25bceda6094fce9d659bbb7a6e82825aa09fb8bc688689825bab19bf5", "AGENTS.md": "b0869db25bceda6094fce9d659bbb7a6e82825aa09fb8bc688689825bab19bf5", "audit-reconciliation.md": "24788599883762240863d1b3fa7811ced2a8df1a1e7df3ad49e37c0d99e5e2ff", "bindings/native-v3.md": "e84e05966567a9dae60833a573e8f3a51d42c83ab60fc05d6a9a1809758e8826", "boundary-decision.md": "21869a9a58190479a9532d886bd44dc4f651c02be5fbe167472113357a7a6fd0", "composition.yaml": "d3c55f3de78c9b532435b1cd8a838ba3a4edcfe377356a659fb32282b8bc3e9c", "crosswalk.json": "b6f2fa9be5397c5ccb1595d3c726467d55b6bb87b2ef851077b9578c12cc0e6e", "examples/ai.json": "553ae660182a557094833770ff9f0216f7e3ed653099f0ffa47b99a4a719829a", "examples/matrix.json": "6e55f11bf2b82d9bb71bc651c438bfcb4592fad0ba1d3bd863f248a1cd248e3a", "examples/startup.json": "f124f732774850c00b4a7ceb8dc0936304bba467e3b10d66777f2d0b312652bd", "final-review-limits.md": "aefcfdcc644d8b7d5027a74fe0918af9af491ded9216897826f0947c5bf39165", "invariants.md": "dc06c2992594e7637c59409472b778bfd3c9988ab0b6ab073ed8d9a31c018257", "lifecycle/transitions.json": "9a68e0d3dc28a4c9e308b746654e0a2c5adaf1d2ebcdedd726da182d393e1b4b", "mastership-and-rights.yaml": "a98b528365f5950ccd3ff0805ad6d4a8c0c4672e53243dac15952ca0bb534d98", "migration.md": "a8448001a91281ce5ba91bded1b387f27df59923391affe45b2b91b92de7a4c2", "model-fields.md": "b59e46af4312aca3707622df45958f59b7ac6b293a77711d18532197b0875a26", "model-spec.md": "e29083b62adc59ec70c731c18b8f824946d39e415e7a6b65055c2cd38bd4b446", "monetary.py": "2154af2ef1b291114ad8ae613f05a8ddc9d7c517fe730ba35218a334fe42d495", "monetary.schema.json": "f0c162531b7506af1b75435cd785e70956254b35c187718c925c1287746d0bcb", "parent-field-crosswalk.json": "7edd40cf333041b36054ac2fa285c21f8f4e036716a27cb194e091f25bdddb02", "publication-manifest.draft": "6ee9a5398a87e8ff22bf206bddd8fe461350d2b092c0fefad1116d843f2e7549", "README.md": "aa719ca700e6f6044b5d25b970378d8c05a6fc046641310c01e5ff21c8f17c77", "requirements.txt": "48ee7d1db1cfddbb445bdff4adca44ee15724e2d52b531d9d5bb7c77e2f1455f", "research.md": "3eef9fb493634f8499d0d73a3a4f4be0ebead8b059a2293199becfd56a4a2760", "review.md": "18350789f154c5b8e4afaf4758b8994013c507df7d46fbc5a8c733e5c829c30a", "runtime-model.reference.json": "fe06fb1af59031cebc8439d75f15f78c9de94088827f2807dddd93a746f9eb52", "source-verification.json": "f3ca53a0133431a7df646acf202e96765663afe70a19c2fd65555ed0c8218b4f", "spec.json": "1cf0eb0451ff09b449da724bbcc64afdc0e34385427c9df8b9b2335d83880c26", "test-results.json": "333a167ed0474f6fa2f63ccbf067fc4373111d6b4ba27f0700c35a5fc1b938e9", "test_monetary.py": "dc5e54fb29d204327f7039f436f9cab080f19625bb7e152df29ada1e885bb3f3", "tool-pins.json": "14d54b08bdbe854a00eda39b8643c73473445312bf2ea4902954eaf716bd9ae7", "whole-object-coverage.yaml": "840345e7cde0af4584b1197c9fbf62e14310b84dee9c78ce8ea48c430c3d0696" }, "candidateFiles": { "acceptance-results.json": "dc3b625c41d6a9ac34e5392c6fa518e232e013f35d3891ca5fbf04e20b55cbce", "acceptance.py": "1bbf5d55cf91f1a13bc2aa366d7eaf021efca61117195bef5335919cc77df7e5", "adoption-limits.md": "e143c64f983dcdbb879323aef44637b9536a56647c98dbceb6a875904bdf93cd", "agent-guide.md": "b0869db25bceda6094fce9d659bbb7a6e82825aa09fb8bc688689825bab19bf5", "AGENTS.md": "b0869db25bceda6094fce9d659bbb7a6e82825aa09fb8bc688689825bab19bf5", "audit-reconciliation.md": "24788599883762240863d1b3fa7811ced2a8df1a1e7df3ad49e37c0d99e5e2ff", "bindings/native-v3.md": "e84e05966567a9dae60833a573e8f3a51d42c83ab60fc05d6a9a1809758e8826", "boundary-decision.md": "21869a9a58190479a9532d886bd44dc4f651c02be5fbe167472113357a7a6fd0", "composition.yaml": "d3c55f3de78c9b532435b1cd8a838ba3a4edcfe377356a659fb32282b8bc3e9c", "crosswalk.json": "b6f2fa9be5397c5ccb1595d3c726467d55b6bb87b2ef851077b9578c12cc0e6e", "examples/ai.json": "553ae660182a557094833770ff9f0216f7e3ed653099f0ffa47b99a4a719829a", "examples/matrix.json": "6e55f11bf2b82d9bb71bc651c438bfcb4592fad0ba1d3bd863f248a1cd248e3a", "examples/startup.json": "f124f732774850c00b4a7ceb8dc0936304bba467e3b10d66777f2d0b312652bd", "final-review-limits.md": "aefcfdcc644d8b7d5027a74fe0918af9af491ded9216897826f0947c5bf39165", "invariants.md": "dc06c2992594e7637c59409472b778bfd3c9988ab0b6ab073ed8d9a31c018257", "lifecycle/transitions.json": "9a68e0d3dc28a4c9e308b746654e0a2c5adaf1d2ebcdedd726da182d393e1b4b", "mastership-and-rights.yaml": "a98b528365f5950ccd3ff0805ad6d4a8c0c4672e53243dac15952ca0bb534d98", "migration.md": "a8448001a91281ce5ba91bded1b387f27df59923391affe45b2b91b92de7a4c2", "model-fields.md": "b59e46af4312aca3707622df45958f59b7ac6b293a77711d18532197b0875a26", "model-spec.md": "e29083b62adc59ec70c731c18b8f824946d39e415e7a6b65055c2cd38bd4b446", "monetary.py": "2154af2ef1b291114ad8ae613f05a8ddc9d7c517fe730ba35218a334fe42d495", "monetary.schema.json": "f0c162531b7506af1b75435cd785e70956254b35c187718c925c1287746d0bcb", "parent-field-crosswalk.json": "7edd40cf333041b36054ac2fa285c21f8f4e036716a27cb194e091f25bdddb02", "publication-addendum.md": "d8996e68077c7839cc6aaef30661a24ddc75cd542445275d3815490900b0d26f", "publication-manifest.draft": "6ee9a5398a87e8ff22bf206bddd8fe461350d2b092c0fefad1116d843f2e7549", "README.md": "aa719ca700e6f6044b5d25b970378d8c05a6fc046641310c01e5ff21c8f17c77", "requirements.txt": "48ee7d1db1cfddbb445bdff4adca44ee15724e2d52b531d9d5bb7c77e2f1455f", "research.md": "3eef9fb493634f8499d0d73a3a4f4be0ebead8b059a2293199becfd56a4a2760", "review.md": "18350789f154c5b8e4afaf4758b8994013c507df7d46fbc5a8c733e5c829c30a", "runtime-model.reference.json": "fe06fb1af59031cebc8439d75f15f78c9de94088827f2807dddd93a746f9eb52", "source-verification.json": "f3ca53a0133431a7df646acf202e96765663afe70a19c2fd65555ed0c8218b4f", "spec.json": "1cf0eb0451ff09b449da724bbcc64afdc0e34385427c9df8b9b2335d83880c26", "test-results.json": "333a167ed0474f6fa2f63ccbf067fc4373111d6b4ba27f0700c35a5fc1b938e9", "test_monetary.py": "dc5e54fb29d204327f7039f436f9cab080f19625bb7e152df29ada1e885bb3f3", "tool-pins.json": "14d54b08bdbe854a00eda39b8643c73473445312bf2ea4902954eaf716bd9ae7", "whole-object-coverage.yaml": "840345e7cde0af4584b1197c9fbf62e14310b84dee9c78ce8ea48c430c3d0696" }, "scopeNotes": "The 35 R4 files are unchanged. Only review.json bookkeeping and publication-addendum.md Codex disclosure are added after freeze; they are not claimed provider-reviewed." }