{ "disposition": "publish bounded reviewable draft", "researchAssurance": "reviewable-draft", "contourStatus": "partial", "decidedAt": "2026-09-22T00:41:15.159464+00:00", "studies": { "Claude": { "provider": "Claude", "requested_model": "opus", "actual_models": [ "claude-opus-5" ], "mode": "independent-cli-web-research", "status": "complete", "started_at": "2026-09-21T22:27:16.990425+00:00", "seconds": 451.88, "prompt_sha256": "d01035159a8150286b1fb4fe461c3b8b8813460c5997763172881bc8dd7744dc", "response_sha256": "bf1e79827e72ebcda978857b1696e42fd42c56f6353cfc5def966be4c6669f48", "permission_denials": [], "tool_uses": [ "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch", "WebFetch" ] }, "Grok": { "provider": "Grok", "mode": "independent-browser-web-research", "status": "complete", "ui_mode": "Heavy", "actual_model": "not exposed by browser UI", "conversation_url": "https://grok.com/c/5d894020-0300-4df2-9c73-6b5eca2484da", "captured_at": "2026-09-21T22:37:12.677541+00:00", "prompt_sha256": "d01035159a8150286b1fb4fe461c3b8b8813460c5997763172881bc8dd7744dc", "response_sha256": "93a1801949cb0d22a53995a8a7dc354f9a574ac18063c9a7c4859a272a7aef9f", "evidence_format": "verbatim browser Copy answer Markdown; not schema-validated provider JSON", "source_limits": "Provider reports summarized web extracts; underlying tool calls, hash verification, model identity and teammate attributions were not independently observed." } }, "providers": { "Claude": { "status": "complete", "disposition": "ACCEPT WITH LIMITS", "manifest": { "provider": "Claude", "requested_model": "opus", "actual_models": [ "claude-opus-5" ], "mode": "frozen-no-tools-audit", "status": "complete", "started_at": "2026-09-22T00:26:49.633444+00:00", "seconds": 307.53, "prompt_sha256": "f69a5e18c7def845c7fc79825bebc8a0180903c75cb0500ab94886b66571cd36", "response_sha256": "4be38cbd78c7eda5c480a3a6786617d63267f51bbdc6515ee774721443da98a2", "permission_denials": [], "tool_uses": [] }, "scope": "Complete frozen candidate supplied; JSON/YAML compact-rendered and Markdown table rows rendered as complete ordered cells. Static no-tools audit; no provider test execution or external source/hash verification." }, "Grok": { "status": "complete", "disposition": "ACCEPT WITH LIMITS", "manifest": { "provider": "Grok", "status": "complete", "mode": "frozen-no-tools-browser-audit", "model_display": "Heavy", "actual_model": "not exposed by browser", "started_at": "2026-09-22T00:28:11.049Z", "completed_at": "2026-09-22T00:39:09.006Z", "conversation_url": "https://grok.com/c/6eee85d9-bb1f-4738-97ad-73d2ff231422?rid=3c3b9cc4-0f0b-420f-b2a4-f6e97048bbe3", "prompt_sha256": "f69a5e18c7def845c7fc79825bebc8a0180903c75cb0500ab94886b66571cd36", "editor_sha256": "c66237bb6f4e34d40b4894ca46a2857d01c3b67044f42676a66ecb0f66fd4b85", "editor_fidelity": "Every nonblank line identical including code; blank paragraph spacing only. Both providers received common ordered-cell rendering of Markdown table rows.", "response_sha256": "e79c7074ea8d5b5254ca4a2790bd4c1f56432c99107af2ee86d2e69e109900b3", "limitations": "Static audit; no execution, external source verification or independent hash computation claimed." }, "scope": "Complete frozen candidate supplied; JSON/YAML compact-rendered and Markdown table rows rendered as complete ordered cells. Static no-tools audit; no provider test execution or external source/hash verification." } }, "auditSummary": "Actual independent Claude and Grok contour studies reused, followed by three separate full-candidate quantity audit rounds. Earlier disagreement is retained: Claude requested revisions; Grok accepted with limits. Both final R3 audits accept this bounded embedded profile with limits. Executed code/native checks are separate Codex evidence.", "publicationHolds": [ "One semantic quantity per existing host in the supplied native binding; no artificial host creation or multi-field native adapter.", "Current host rights, source/definition/context evidence and slot inventory must be established externally.", "Same-writer/master/access and same input kind/dimension/anchor/role/context correction only; no current-head or derived-staleness selector.", "Exact scalar/affine subset, Python reference and per-record bounds; no full standards or production certification.", "EM-XCT-06 remains partial. Price/FX, calendars, localization, uncertainty and wider bindings have explicit follow-up assignments." ], "reviewedFiles": { "acceptance-results.json": "397b7ecc41e340d0f1038ee6382eb061b70e82dd2b425c94c6c985185ec4a07b", "acceptance.py": "b12d66f56f32270268e11617cd9dc2b74a418bbe5de1bd3b5d7a41275b2f8507", "adoption-limits.md": "979722da4285a1e867b11cea093b8baabf2f89f0e1cd53ea245163753493d996", "agent-guide.md": "09d187964cf54837d3070d16a00630cd9468c214880244fe69461d6b7f3f3d06", "AGENTS.md": "8975c85898ff25ac09825d6a274a4cb11aa057f83dcedec9d7e998c2d3b09663", "audit-reconciliation.md": "6e7bb160610f5835d3cb6d00a23bbc93af8e2f426455e7a411009039b0792589", "bindings/native-v3.md": "4c27322f39861b2a94c663bc3bf6980d90fb84bed0aa1bf9f6690c86d3d428a7", "boundary-decision.md": "0ff7a7e7fd24e9915a44675ca83a4be55628e5166889bfa84383b6bf8907724b", "composition.yaml": "81f653e43943b8a7017929967c67500b066760cb151d981a6c8749bf4e033ab8", "crosswalk.json": "6396cff815d9f6d46221ae2a9686f49a20b9071ab7725a297a6e76664d1a3ddf", "examples/ai.json": "c423f36fbc9a0d00173f1950a5e1730ff5a1dfd7c76e787f68e8d3d4f6469a30", "examples/matrix.json": "a95a6e169d72e4737ba038bc4cd82a11f71dfd217c70126044a38f2a2e7c313d", "examples/startup.json": "31bc178fbc735a7e57ef36323ce4238f7e2c0f45d915590ab03543c2d3d6d008", "invariants.md": "605eae535386f1a54e8907b16157ab70f96a7903159504098faa2dbba03a2d72", "lifecycle/embedded.md": "be41835b16a42bd74457dbfdf7e5e20a7861e3b42dd188a600fb0b93af8eb463", "mastership-and-rights.yaml": "17788ec767047573953aa6f18094e7cdb04746e1ae2c7e27cfe0d9a46036d4f4", "migration.md": "ce360a144d3a33b3da592ebdb6ebc9c128af3b8d2616f21242792d8122b51dd4", "model-fields.md": "be8702e11dbb6e3b594c7842de57e0e604896671224f2353424aa87a96aba53c", "model-spec.md": "0612adab24b91a861791bbd33bcd3fa13522a7025c958f3ee239c3cd0fd627c7", "publication-manifest.draft": "db72bf5bb67e7a115e3e820ec3b0155bf85fca978f3c13fab78e54295cc435bd", "quantity.py": "025ad3f5997f8916665e5cd0485d8ee04996ac6c540d0b1c12244e0d0c625af3", "quantity.schema.json": "d1c5aa2301877ea6b1cf60fab695b203e4a3e43bc3af49a11894d5e60763c73d", "README.md": "2dfe085dac5518870ff34ddf20cb190d987f2d581bbae8f52057ff59b3dcfba1", "requirements.txt": "48ee7d1db1cfddbb445bdff4adca44ee15724e2d52b531d9d5bb7c77e2f1455f", "research.md": "b00b1a2e2bda97146bce3281fb8868fde14657357d4abfab392b7f5be9cd8777", "review.md": "391acf4fd711db1116502ddeb96838cac4a4525c2a185e37d888d9a3cb251746", "runtime-model.reference.json": "fa1c30a159acf9e214d2dee30e9e70505c01d8c9fb1f735422cf2a2333e0b17f", "source-verification.json": "a82ea36c8b49e62647280ea3c4e06dfbdea7134f130838ce768e73018443b8a3", "spec.json": "75476ef5c44a4c28c51787f891f2805cbaf0496141e90efb44f6f16c550aebea", "test-results.json": "bbff6a413d98afe36d0675bc0a38032b9b86e80b54faad98dd141275eeaed303", "test_quantity.py": "2ff8662af15227219c658ea26fdb343b246ae4cf6fe749418e882ef5111914a5", "tool-pins.json": "14d54b08bdbe854a00eda39b8643c73473445312bf2ea4902954eaf716bd9ae7", "whole-object-coverage.yaml": "55664c56b475579b4b9a07c086decae4896fc355169bd02b7424cc1a8a05fcbf" }, "candidateFiles": { "acceptance-results.json": "397b7ecc41e340d0f1038ee6382eb061b70e82dd2b425c94c6c985185ec4a07b", "acceptance.py": "b12d66f56f32270268e11617cd9dc2b74a418bbe5de1bd3b5d7a41275b2f8507", "adoption-limits.md": "979722da4285a1e867b11cea093b8baabf2f89f0e1cd53ea245163753493d996", "agent-guide.md": "09d187964cf54837d3070d16a00630cd9468c214880244fe69461d6b7f3f3d06", "AGENTS.md": "8975c85898ff25ac09825d6a274a4cb11aa057f83dcedec9d7e998c2d3b09663", "audit-reconciliation.md": "6e7bb160610f5835d3cb6d00a23bbc93af8e2f426455e7a411009039b0792589", "bindings/native-v3.md": "4c27322f39861b2a94c663bc3bf6980d90fb84bed0aa1bf9f6690c86d3d428a7", "boundary-decision.md": "0ff7a7e7fd24e9915a44675ca83a4be55628e5166889bfa84383b6bf8907724b", "composition.yaml": "81f653e43943b8a7017929967c67500b066760cb151d981a6c8749bf4e033ab8", "crosswalk.json": "6396cff815d9f6d46221ae2a9686f49a20b9071ab7725a297a6e76664d1a3ddf", "examples/ai.json": "c423f36fbc9a0d00173f1950a5e1730ff5a1dfd7c76e787f68e8d3d4f6469a30", "examples/matrix.json": "a95a6e169d72e4737ba038bc4cd82a11f71dfd217c70126044a38f2a2e7c313d", "examples/startup.json": "31bc178fbc735a7e57ef36323ce4238f7e2c0f45d915590ab03543c2d3d6d008", "invariants.md": "605eae535386f1a54e8907b16157ab70f96a7903159504098faa2dbba03a2d72", "lifecycle/embedded.md": "be41835b16a42bd74457dbfdf7e5e20a7861e3b42dd188a600fb0b93af8eb463", "mastership-and-rights.yaml": "17788ec767047573953aa6f18094e7cdb04746e1ae2c7e27cfe0d9a46036d4f4", "migration.md": "ce360a144d3a33b3da592ebdb6ebc9c128af3b8d2616f21242792d8122b51dd4", "model-fields.md": "be8702e11dbb6e3b594c7842de57e0e604896671224f2353424aa87a96aba53c", "model-spec.md": "0612adab24b91a861791bbd33bcd3fa13522a7025c958f3ee239c3cd0fd627c7", "publication-manifest.draft": "db72bf5bb67e7a115e3e820ec3b0155bf85fca978f3c13fab78e54295cc435bd", "quantity.py": "025ad3f5997f8916665e5cd0485d8ee04996ac6c540d0b1c12244e0d0c625af3", "quantity.schema.json": "d1c5aa2301877ea6b1cf60fab695b203e4a3e43bc3af49a11894d5e60763c73d", "README.md": "2dfe085dac5518870ff34ddf20cb190d987f2d581bbae8f52057ff59b3dcfba1", "requirements.txt": "48ee7d1db1cfddbb445bdff4adca44ee15724e2d52b531d9d5bb7c77e2f1455f", "research.md": "b00b1a2e2bda97146bce3281fb8868fde14657357d4abfab392b7f5be9cd8777", "review.md": "391acf4fd711db1116502ddeb96838cac4a4525c2a185e37d888d9a3cb251746", "runtime-model.reference.json": "fa1c30a159acf9e214d2dee30e9e70505c01d8c9fb1f735422cf2a2333e0b17f", "source-verification.json": "a82ea36c8b49e62647280ea3c4e06dfbdea7134f130838ce768e73018443b8a3", "spec.json": "75476ef5c44a4c28c51787f891f2805cbaf0496141e90efb44f6f16c550aebea", "test-results.json": "bbff6a413d98afe36d0675bc0a38032b9b86e80b54faad98dd141275eeaed303", "test_quantity.py": "2ff8662af15227219c658ea26fdb343b246ae4cf6fe749418e882ef5111914a5", "tool-pins.json": "14d54b08bdbe854a00eda39b8643c73473445312bf2ea4902954eaf716bd9ae7", "whole-object-coverage.yaml": "55664c56b475579b4b9a07c086decae4896fc355169bd02b7424cc1a8a05fcbf", "publication-addendum.md": "a2677fc5417375cdb381653fa64249664091df7b7fb22e4798a19368ca352e71" }, "scopeNotes": "All 33 frozen candidate files unchanged. review.json and publication-addendum.md are post-audit Codex bookkeeping/disclosure, not provider-reviewed candidate content. The addendum makes final correction, target-unit and diagnostic adoption limits explicit.", "requiredReading": [ "AGENTS.md", "model-spec.md", "adoption-limits.md", "bindings/native-v3.md", "publication-addendum.md" ], "adoptionNotice": "Read the publication addendum before adoption. Every correction requires the retained predecessor and an explicit validate_correction call; head-only validation is insufficient. Read each conversion result with its own target, and govern unit/target changes explicitly. Native reference: one semantic quantity per existing host." }