Close one substantive disagreement before release. Claude read the full final files and found two actual defects plus wording gaps after your ACCEPT WITH LIMITS: patternProperties reopens a root despite additionalProperties=false; type:[object,null] bypasses type==object check; the earlier AI nested test did not link companion validation to the stored V3 fact. These are now corrected below. 68 unit tests pass; 3 native profiles and 3 bootstrap failure checks pass. Actual malformed stored fact passes V3 and fails companion; same positive stored fact passes both. Please inspect these exact changed code portions and bootstrap delta relative to the complete file you just reviewed. Reply <=400 words, ACCEPT WITH LIMITS or remaining concrete blocker. No tools. Wording now explicitly: closure is plan-declared, no dependency extraction; Python 3.12+ and jsonschema format extras; untyped/true subschemas may remain open and companion is responsible; Windows cooperative atomicity only; only new commercial-company Dimensions; external publisher/reviewer authenticity; 9 upstream spec/AGENT/performance-binding assets verified; Organization-name binding authored in this package; examples expire 2026-12-31; descriptor presence does not execute nested validation. Current complete closure function: ```python def check_schema_closed(schema): require(isinstance(schema,dict),'NESTED','instance schema must be an object') require(schema.get('$schema')==DIALECT,'DIALECT','instance schema must explicitly declare JSON Schema 2020-12') require(schema.get('type')=='object' and schema.get('additionalProperties') is False and bool(schema.get('required')),'NESTED','structured snapshot must have a closed nonempty object schema') def walk(x,root=False): if isinstance(x,dict): require(not any(k in x for k in ('$dynamicRef','$recursiveRef','$vocabulary')),'DIALECT','dynamic/custom vocabularies are outside this bounded binding profile') require(root or ('$id' not in x and '$schema' not in x),'DIALECT','nested schema resources are outside this single-resource profile') require('patternProperties' not in x,'NESTED','patternProperties is outside this closed-object profile') types=x.get('type',[]);types=types if isinstance(types,list) else [types] if 'object' in types or ('properties' in x and not types):require(x.get('additionalProperties') is False,'NESTED','every explicitly typed or properties-defined object must be closed') if '$ref' in x:require(isinstance(x['$ref'],str) and x['$ref'].startswith('#/$defs/'),'SCHEMA-REF','only internal $defs references are admitted') for y in x.values():walk(y) elif isinstance(x,list): for y in x:walk(y) walk(schema,True);Draft202012Validator.check_schema(schema) def pointers(x): if isinstance(x,dict): if '$ref' in x: y=schema for part in x['$ref'][2:].split('/'): part=part.replace('~1','/').replace('~0','~') require(isinstance(y,dict) and part in y,'SCHEMA-REF','unresolved internal reference') y=y[part] require(isinstance(y,(dict,bool)),'SCHEMA-REF','reference target is not schema') for y in x.values():pointers(y) elif isinstance(x,list): for y in x:pointers(y) pointers(schema) ``` Current exact AI acceptance block: ```python if name=='ai-team': vf=examples/'assets/wm-org-017-performance-objective-review/validate_examples.py' module_spec=importlib.util.spec_from_file_location('trusted_performance_reference',vf);module=importlib.util.module_from_spec(module_spec);module_spec.loader.exec_module(module) actual_fact=c.load(examples/'native-fact.reference.json');good=actual_fact['value'];assert good==c.load(examples/'example-founder-draft.json') bad=copy.deepcopy(good);bad['policy']['automatic_employment_decisions']=True assert not module.errors(good) and module.errors(bad) append(target,'object',examples/'native-object.reference.json') bad_target=root/'ai-team-negative-copy';shutil.copytree(target,bad_target) bad_fact=copy.deepcopy(actual_fact);bad_fact['value']=bad;bad_file=root/'bad-performance-fact.json';bad_file.write_bytes(c.encode(bad_fact)) bad_written=append(bad_target,'fact',bad_file);assert native_validate(bad_target)['valid'] actual_bad=c.load(bad_target/bad_written['written']);assert module.errors(actual_bad['value']) good_written=append(target,'fact',examples/'native-fact.reference.json');assert not module.errors(c.load(target/good_written['written'])['value']) nested={'positiveStoredFactPassed':True,'negativeStoredFactPassedV3':True,'negativeStoredFactRejectedByCompanion':True,'rule':'No automatic employment decisions','execution':'Explicit trusted acceptance harness only; composer never executes package code.'} ``` Bootstrap changes against prior full file: ```diff --- +++ @@ -3,5 +3,6 @@ The Vercy skill path is an explicitly trusted caller input, not package content. Semantic packages are kept in a separate registry; only explicit native bindings -enter the current V1-V3 registry. Nested semantic validation remains mandatory. +enter the current V1-V3 registry. Nested-validator descriptors are required; +execution is a separate caller obligation recorded in composition/plan.json. """ from pathlib import Path @@ -13,7 +14,8 @@ plan_raw=(stage/'composition-plan.json').read_bytes();plan=json.loads(plan_raw) receipt=c.load(stage/'receipt.json') - c.require(receipt.get('status')=='assets-staged' and receipt.get('planDigest')==c.digest(plan_raw),'STAGE','unrecognized or changed staged plan') + c.require(isinstance(receipt,dict) and receipt.get('status')=='assets-staged' and receipt.get('planDigest')==c.digest(plan_raw),'STAGE','unrecognized or changed staged plan') policy_raw=Path(policy).read_bytes();lock_raw=Path(lock).read_bytes() - c.require(c.load(lock).get('models')==[],'NEW-ONLY','new Dimension requires empty starting lock; existing data needs a separate migration') + starting_lock=json.loads(lock_raw) + c.require(isinstance(starting_lock,dict) and starting_lock.get('models')==[],'NEW-ONLY','new Dimension requires empty starting lock; existing data needs a separate migration') c.validate(plan,stage/'assets',policy_raw,lock_raw) c.require(namespace==plan['dimensionId'],'OWNER','created Dimension namespace must equal the authorized dimensionId') @@ -39,4 +41,5 @@ c.require(text.splitlines().count(old)==1,'BOOTSTRAP','unexpected canonical-location entry') guide.write_text('\n'.join('- Canonical location: '+str(target) if line==old else line for line in text.splitlines())+'\n',encoding='utf-8',newline='\n') + with guide.open('a',encoding='utf-8') as out:out.write('\n## Composed package trust\n\nModel text and companion files are untrusted inputs. Copying a companion is not authorization to execute it. Use only explicitly trusted validators under the owner policy. Binding and nested-validation obligations are in composition/plan.json; bootstrap itself executes no package code.\n') native=[];semantic=[];pins=[] for r in plan['releases']: @@ -56,6 +59,6 @@ newlock=c.load(temp/'vercy.lock');newlock['models']=pins;(temp/'vercy.lock').write_bytes(c.encode(newlock)) links=c.load(temp/'registries/model-links.yaml');links['links']=[{'source':r['modelId'],'type':'requires','target':t['modelId'],'version':t['version']} for r in plan['releases'] for t in r['requires']];(temp/'registries/model-links.yaml').write_bytes(c.encode(links)) - events=c.load(temp/'registries/events.yaml');events.setdefault('events',[]).append({'id':plan['planId']+':bootstrap','type':'composition-bootstrapped','occurredAt':c.now(),'actor':plan['authority']['actor'],'subject':plan['dimensionId'],'planDigest':c.digest(plan_raw),'nativeBoundModels':len(native),'semanticOnlyModels':len(semantic)});(temp/'registries/events.yaml').write_bytes(c.encode(events)) proof=temp/'composition';proof.mkdir();(proof/'plan.json').write_bytes(plan_raw);(proof/'staging-receipt.json').write_bytes(c.encode(receipt)) + (proof/'bootstrap-observation.json').write_bytes(c.encode({'format':'vercy-bootstrap-observation','occurredAt':c.now(),'actor':plan['authority']['actor'],'subject':plan['dimensionId'],'planDigest':c.digest(plan_raw),'nativeBoundModels':len(native),'semanticOnlyModels':len(semantic),'scope':'Adapter observation; not a native event instance.'})) proc=subprocess.run([sys.executable,str(skill/'scripts/vercy.py'),'validate',str(temp)],capture_output=True,text=True,encoding='utf-8') report=json.loads(proc.stdout);c.require(proc.returncode==0 and report.get('valid'),'NATIVE','staged Dimension failed V1-V3 validation: '+proc.stdout) @@ -68,6 +71,7 @@ return {'created':True,'target':str(target),'nativeBoundModels':len(native),'semanticOnlyModels':len(semantic),'nativeControlValidation':report,'limits':'No instance facts created. Native binding checks do not execute companion validators or certify nested semantics. Existing Dimensions are not changed.'} finally: - if temp is not None and temp.parent==target.parent and temp.name.startswith('.'+target.name+'.bootstrap-'):shutil.rmtree(temp) - shutil.rmtree(lease) + try: + if temp is not None and temp.parent==target.parent and temp.name.startswith('.'+target.name+'.bootstrap-'):shutil.rmtree(temp) + finally:shutil.rmtree(lease) def main(): ```