{"schema":"https://ver.cy/schemas/card/1.0.0","id":"vr.tr.contradictory","code":"thing-contradictory","url":"https://ver.cy/models/thing/contradictory/","name":"contradictory","alternateNames":[],"kind":"thing","status":"published","version":"0.2.0-wave.2","language":"en","classifiers":{"family":"Thing Registry","category":"Cross-cutting context","entryKind":"noun.relation","plane":"XCT","domain":["XCT.REL"],"industry":[],"navPath":"","tags":[],"facets":{"substance":"abstract","origin":"conceptual","agency":"inert","mobility":"not-applicable","scale":"not-applicable","affordances":["observable"]}},"whatItIs":"In logic, the relation between two propositions that cannot both be true and cannot both be false, so that exactly one of them holds, as between a statement and its negation or between the universal affirmative and the particular negative in the traditional square of opposition; contradictories differ from contraries, which cannot both be true but can both be false, and the relation underpins proof by contradiction and consistency checks.","purpose":"Let an agent explain the contradictory relation in logic, distinguish it from contrariety and other oppositions, identify contradictories of given statements, and support reasoning and teaching.","scope":{"in":[],"out":[],"boundaries":[]},"distinguishingFeatures":["Opposite truth values","Negation","Square of opposition","Proof use"],"structure":{"bundles":[{"id":"understand","name":"Understand","description":"The relation.","layers":[{"id":"definition","name":"Definition","description":"Definition.","findings":[{"id":"definition-finding","name":"Definition","description":"Definition.","questions":[{"text":"What makes two propositions contradictories, and how does this differ from contraries and subcontraries?","kind":"definition"},{"text":"Is the logical sense or everyday inconsistency meant?","kind":"boundary"}]}]},{"id":"square","name":"Square","description":"Square of opposition.","findings":[{"id":"square-finding","name":"Square","description":"Square.","questions":[{"text":"How do contradictories appear in the traditional square of opposition?","kind":"definition"},{"text":"Which entry fits the square of opposition?","kind":"action"}]}]}]},{"id":"apply","name":"Apply","description":"Using contradictories.","layers":[{"id":"negate","name":"Negate","description":"Forming contradictories.","findings":[{"id":"negate-finding","name":"Negate","description":"Negation.","questions":[{"text":"What is the contradictory of this statement, including quantified and modal statements?","kind":"action"},{"text":"Which errors are common in negation?","kind":"provenance"}]}]},{"id":"proof","name":"Proof","description":"Proof and consistency.","findings":[{"id":"proof-finding","name":"Proof","description":"Proof.","questions":[{"text":"How are contradictories used in proof by contradiction and in checking consistency?","kind":"definition"},{"text":"Which entry fits proof methods?","kind":"action"}]}]}]},{"id":"theory","name":"Theory","description":"Formal treatment.","layers":[{"id":"formal","name":"Formal","description":"Formal logic.","findings":[{"id":"formal-finding","name":"Formal","description":"Formal.","questions":[{"text":"How is contradiction formalised in classical, intuitionistic and paraconsistent logics?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which references are standard?","kind":"provenance"}]}]},{"id":"philosophy","name":"Philosophy","description":"Philosophy.","findings":[{"id":"philosophy-finding","name":"Philosophy","description":"Philosophy.","questions":[{"text":"How have philosophers treated the law of non-contradiction and dialetheism, with positions attributed?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which entry fits a specific philosopher?","kind":"action"}]}]}]},{"id":"learn","name":"Learn","description":"Teaching.","layers":[{"id":"teach","name":"Teach","description":"Teaching oppositions.","findings":[{"id":"teach-finding","name":"Teach","description":"Teaching.","questions":[{"text":"How can contradictories and contraries be taught with examples and diagrams?","kind":"action"},{"text":"Which misconceptions arise?","kind":"provenance"}]}]},{"id":"language","name":"Language","description":"Everyday usage.","findings":[{"id":"language-finding","name":"Language","description":"Language.","questions":[{"text":"How is contradictory used in everyday language and law, and how does it differ from the logical sense?","kind":"definition"},{"text":"Which entry fits argumentation?","kind":"action"}]}]}]}]},"agentConduct":{"may":["Form the contradictory of a proposition, including quantified statements, correctly.","Check whether two statements are contradictories or merely contraries."],"mustNot":["Call two statements contradictory when both could be false.","Negate a quantified statement incorrectly and present the result as its contradictory.","Accuse a person of contradicting themselves without showing the two statements conflict."],"requiresHuman":["Using a claimed contradiction to discredit a witness or party in a formal process."]},"ethics":{"considerations":["Accusing someone of self-contradiction damages their credibility and should be accurate."],"affectedParties":["Students of logic","People quoted in debates"]},"owners":{"steward":"Nobody owns the concept; it is held in common by logic.","roles":[],"masterSystems":[]},"relations":[{"target":"oewn-13805250-n","type":"parent","note":"registry parent class"},{"target":"logical relation","type":"related","note":"category"},{"target":"contrary","type":"related","note":"the neighbouring opposition"},{"target":"difference","type":"related","note":"a broader relation"},{"target":"complementarity","type":"related","note":"contrast with completion"}],"interaction":{"identity":{"applicability":"required","items":["Vercy registry: vr.tr.contradictory","Open English WordNet: oewn-13805471-n"]},"properties":{"applicability":"not-applicable","items":[]},"recognition":{"applicability":"optional","items":["Exactly one of two propositions is true","Statement and negation","Contraries can both be false","Not physical; a logical relation."]},"capabilities":{"applicability":"required","items":["explain the relation","distinguish from contrariety","identify contradictories","support reasoning"]},"hazards":{"applicability":"required","items":["Confusing contradictories with contraries","Misforming negations of quantified statements","Treating everyday contradiction loosely"]},"interfaces":{"applicability":"required","items":["Conventions of formal logic","No regulation"]},"context":{"applicability":"required","items":["Propositions that cannot share a truth value.","contradictories in propositional logic","contradictories in the square of opposition","contradictory predicates and terms","contradictions in argument and consistency"]}},"sources":[{"title":"Open English WordNet 2024, synset oewn-13805471-n","url":"https://en-word.net/id/oewn-13805471-n","note":"sense and gloss of the concept"},{"title":"Wiktionary: contradictory","url":"https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/contradictory","note":"word senses and usage"}],"openQuestions":["Should the square of opposition be a separate entry?","How should logic textbooks be linked?","How should everyday usage be documented?"],"resources":{"spec":"/models/things/publications/thing-contradictory/spec.json"},"provenance":{"origin":"thing registry research (pass 2)","builtFrom":["models/things/publications/thing-contradictory/spec.json"],"providers":["Claude"],"researchStatus":"unreviewed","generatedAt":"2026-09-12T00:17:05Z","builder":"tools/build_cards.py@1.0.0"},"completeness":{"sections":{"classifiers":"filled","whatItIs":"filled","purpose":"filled","distinguishingFeatures":"filled","structure":"filled","agentConduct":"filled","ethics":"filled","owners":"filled","relations":"filled","interaction.identity":"filled","interaction.properties":"not-applicable","interaction.recognition":"filled","interaction.capabilities":"filled","interaction.hazards":"filled","interaction.interfaces":"filled","interaction.context":"filled","sources":"filled"},"notes":{"_gate":"Published through the thing publication gate 1.0 on 2026-10-07T12:16:27+00:00: completeness 1.00; sense: WordNet gloss; 2 live sources; review by codex: pass","interaction.properties":"Plane XCT: no invented physical properties."},"score":1.0}}