{"schema":"https://ver.cy/schemas/card/1.0.0","id":"vr.tr.minister-of-state","code":"thing-q2632935","url":"https://ver.cy/models/thing/q2632935/","name":"minister of state","alternateNames":["Minister of State for Budget and National Planning","Minister of Information","Bavarian Minister of Agriculture and Forestry","Bavarian minister of finance","Bavarian minister of economics","Bavaria's interior minister","Bavarian Minister of the Interior, Construction and Transportation","Minister of State for Women and Family","Minister of State (Greece)","Minister of State for Foreign Affairs","Minister of State","Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs"],"kind":"thing","status":"published","version":"0.2.0-wave.2","language":"en","classifiers":{"family":"Thing Registry","category":"Society, people and institutions","entryKind":"thing","plane":"SOC","domain":["SOC.PER"],"industry":[],"navPath":"","tags":[],"facets":{}},"whatItIs":"A minister assigned to assist a specific cabinet minister, holding delegated responsibilities within that minister's portfolio and with rank and powers defined by the government concerned; this sense excludes uses of the same title for full cabinet ministers or senior ministers who do not serve in such an assisting role.","purpose":"Let an agent explain the role of a minister of state assisting a specific cabinet minister, identify holders of such posts with sources, describe their delegated responsibilities and country-specific rank, distinguish other uses of the title, and support civic questions.","scope":{"in":[],"out":[],"boundaries":[]},"distinguishingFeatures":["Variable rank","Delegated portfolios","Country-specific","Common in Westminster systems"],"structure":{"bundles":[{"id":"understand","name":"Understand","description":"What the title means.","layers":[{"id":"concept","name":"Concept","description":"Title by country.","findings":[{"id":"concept-finding","name":"Concept","description":"Concept.","questions":[{"text":"What does minister of state mean in the United Kingdom, Ireland, India, Bavaria, France, Nigeria and elsewhere?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which country is meant?","kind":"boundary"}]}]},{"id":"rank","name":"Rank","description":"Rank and responsibilities.","findings":[{"id":"rank-finding","name":"Rank","description":"Rank.","questions":[{"text":"What rank and delegated responsibilities does the office hold in a given system?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which entry fits a specific ministry?","kind":"action"}]}]}]},{"id":"identify","name":"Identify","description":"Office holders.","layers":[{"id":"holders","name":"Holders","description":"Current and past holders.","findings":[{"id":"holders-finding","name":"Holders","description":"Holders.","questions":[{"text":"Who holds a given minister of state post, according to official sources?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Is the information current?","kind":"boundary"}]}]},{"id":"appointment","name":"Appointment","description":"Appointment.","findings":[{"id":"appointment-finding","name":"Appointment","description":"Appointment.","questions":[{"text":"How are ministers of state appointed and dismissed?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which entry fits government formation?","kind":"action"}]}]}]},{"id":"civic","name":"Civic","description":"Civic engagement.","layers":[{"id":"contact","name":"Contact","description":"Engaging with the office.","findings":[{"id":"contact-finding","name":"Contact","description":"Contact.","questions":[{"text":"How can the public engage with a minister of state on their portfolio?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which entry fits a specific portfolio?","kind":"action"}]}]},{"id":"accountability","name":"Accountability","description":"Accountability.","findings":[{"id":"accountability-finding","name":"Accountability","description":"Accountability.","questions":[{"text":"How are ministers of state held accountable to parliament and codes of conduct?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Is the presentation neutral?","kind":"boundary"}]}]}]},{"id":"learn","name":"Learn","description":"History and comparison.","layers":[{"id":"history","name":"History","description":"History.","findings":[{"id":"history-finding","name":"History","description":"History.","questions":[{"text":"How did the title develop in different systems?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which references are standard?","kind":"provenance"}]}]},{"id":"compare","name":"Compare","description":"Comparison.","findings":[{"id":"compare-finding","name":"Compare","description":"Comparison.","questions":[{"text":"How do junior and senior ministerial ranks compare across countries?","kind":"provenance"},{"text":"Which misconceptions arise?","kind":"provenance"}]}]}]}]},"agentConduct":{"may":["Explain what minister of state means in each country, keeping the meanings distinct.","Report office holders and portfolios from official government sources."],"mustNot":["Present a minister of state in one country as having the powers of the title elsewhere.","Spread false statements about office holders.","Impersonate a minister or their office.","Present outdated appointments as current."],"requiresHuman":["Drafting communications on a minister's behalf."]},"ethics":{"considerations":["Accurate information on who holds power supports accountability.","Impersonation of officials is used in fraud."],"affectedParties":["Citizens","Office holders","Civil servants"]},"owners":{"steward":"The government that appoints the office under its constitution.","roles":[],"masterSystems":["Official government gazettes"]},"relations":[{"target":"Q83307","type":"parent","note":"registry parent class"},{"target":"minister","type":"related","note":"category"},{"target":"education minister","type":"related","note":"another ministerial office entry"},{"target":"defence minister","type":"related","note":"another ministerial office entry"},{"target":"lieutenant governor","type":"related","note":"another deputy office entry"}],"interaction":{"identity":{"applicability":"required","items":["Vercy registry: vr.tr.minister-of-state","Wikidata: Q2632935 (https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2632935)"]},"properties":{"applicability":"not-applicable","items":[]},"recognition":{"applicability":"optional","items":["The minister assists a specific cabinet minister.","The minister holds delegated responsibilities with country-specific rank and powers.","Other uses of the title for full cabinet or senior ministers fall outside this sense.","Not physical; a government office."]},"capabilities":{"applicability":"required","items":["explain the title by country","identify holders","describe responsibilities","support civic questions"]},"hazards":{"applicability":"required","items":["Assuming one country meaning applies elsewhere","Outdated office holders","Confusing with secretaries of state"]},"interfaces":{"applicability":"required","items":["Constitutional and statutory provisions on ministers","Ministerial codes of conduct","Government formation rules"]},"context":{"applicability":"required","items":["A ministerial title of varying rank.","ministers of state in Westminster systems","Bavarian and German state ministers","French ministers of state","ministers of state in Nigeria and other countries","historical ministers of state"]}},"sources":[{"title":"Wikidata item Q2632935: minister of state","url":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2632935","note":"identity and sense of the item"},{"title":"Wikipedia: Minister of State","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minister_of_State","note":"general description of the item"}],"openQuestions":["Should each country usage be a separate entry?","How should government directories be linked?","How should responsibilities be documented?"],"resources":{"spec":"/models/things/publications/thing-q2632935/spec.json"},"provenance":{"origin":"thing registry research (pass 2)","builtFrom":["models/things/publications/thing-q2632935/spec.json"],"providers":["Claude"],"researchStatus":"unreviewed","generatedAt":"2026-09-12T03:14:16Z","builder":"tools/build_cards.py@1.0.0"},"completeness":{"sections":{"classifiers":"filled","whatItIs":"filled","purpose":"filled","distinguishingFeatures":"filled","structure":"filled","agentConduct":"filled","ethics":"filled","owners":"filled","relations":"filled","interaction.identity":"filled","interaction.properties":"not-applicable","interaction.recognition":"filled","interaction.capabilities":"filled","interaction.hazards":"filled","interaction.interfaces":"filled","interaction.context":"filled","sources":"filled"},"notes":{"_gate":"Published through the thing publication gate 1.0 on 2026-10-07T10:10:29+00:00: completeness 1.00; sense: Wikidata description; 2 live sources; review by codex: pass","interaction.properties":"Plane SOC: no invented physical properties."},"score":1.0}}