← Back to catalogue
Published

Audit, review and finding

EM-RSK-02 · em-rsk-02

Review plan, criteria, sample, evidence, finding and corrective action. An audit opinion has a scope and limitations.

Enterprise profiles Enterprise subject EnterpriseRSK

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

2 bundles · 3 layers · 4 findings · 9 questions

Audit scope What is reviewed, against which criteria and with which coverage.

Plan and criteria

The audit plan, pinned criteria, scope and exclusions.

Criteria and scope

The criteria version and the units, systems and sites in scope.

  1. Which criteria and which version of them did the audit use?
  2. Which processes, systems and sites were in scope and which were excluded?

Sample

The sample drawn and what population it represents.

  1. How was the sample drawn, and from which population?
  2. What does the sample allow to be concluded, and what not?
Findings and opinion What the audit found, what it concludes and how findings close.

Finding

A finding with its criterion, evidence and condition observed.

Finding evidence

The evidence supporting a finding and its link to criteria.

  1. Which evidence supports the finding, and against which criterion?
  2. Is the finding kept separate from the related risk and remediation task?

Closure and opinion

Corrective action, its verification and the opinion's limits.

Verified closure

Closure of a finding only after independent verification.

  1. Has the corrective action been verified independently?
  2. Does the opinion state its coverage and limitations?
  3. Does any statement extend the opinion beyond its scope?

Classifiers Filled

Family
Enterprise profiles
Category
Enterprise subject
Entry kind
subject
Domain
EnterpriseRSK
Industry
Cross-industry
Tags
EM-RSK-02W2subjectAuditAuditProcedureAuditFindingAssuranceOpinionCorrectiveAction

What it is Filled

Review plan, criteria, sample, evidence, finding and corrective action. An audit opinion has a scope and limitations.

Why it exists Filled

Review plan, criteria, sample, evidence, finding and corrective action. An audit opinion has a scope and limitations.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • An audit opinion is bounded by its scope, criteria and sample; it never covers what was not reviewed.
  • A finding is distinct from the risk it relates to and from the task that remediates it.
  • A finding closes only after independent verification, not when the task is marked done.
  • Distinct from risk assessment, which estimates exposure rather than reports observed conditions.

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Extend the conclusion of a review of one system to the whole group.
  • Close a finding because its remediation task was completed.
  • Change audit criteria after fieldwork without recording the change.
  • Alter or remove evidence attached to a finding.
  • Present a sample result as a statement about the whole population without basis.

Only with a human decision

  • Issuing or signing an audit opinion.
  • Accepting a finding as risk instead of correcting it.
  • Verifying closure of a significant finding.

May

  • List findings with their criteria, evidence and verification status.
  • Report the scope and exclusions of an audit opinion.
  • Flag findings whose remediation task is closed but not verified.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Auditor independence protects stakeholders from self-serving assurance.
  • Overstated opinions can mislead investors, regulators and customers.
  • Findings about named staff touch reputation and employment.

Who is affected

  • Audited units and their staff
  • Boards and audit committees
  • Regulators, investors and customers

Owners Filled

Steward

The risk owner, the information security lead or internal audit, depending on the record.

Master systems

  • GRC platform
  • Identity and access management system
  • SIEM
  • Service desk

Links to other meta-models Filled

neighbor

  • EM-RSK-01
  • EM-WRK-01
  • EM-WRK-02

references

  • WM-ACT-033 - conceptual-candidate
  • WM-ECO-035 - conceptual-candidate
  • WM-KNW-014 - conceptual-candidate

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • Identified by an audit engagement identifier; each finding and corrective action has its own identifier.

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

Enterprise record contour: physical properties belong to referenced world models.

Recognition optional Filled

  • A record names criteria, a scope, an evidence reference and a finding status.
  • Often confused with an internal review note, a risk or a remediation ticket.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • Opinions can be traced back to criteria, samples and evidence.
  • Re-verification of findings keeps the opinion boundary intact.

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Scope creep where an opinion is read as covering excluded areas.
  • Premature closure of findings through task status alone.
  • Loss of evidence integrity when files are edited after review.

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • ISO 19011 guidelines for auditing management systems.
  • IIA Global Internal Audit Standards from the Institute of Internal Auditors.
  • ISAE 3000 from the IAASB for assurance engagements.

Context of use required Filled

  • Used by internal audit, external assurance providers and certification bodies.
  • Applies to financial, security, quality and compliance reviews.

Sources Filled

  1. NIST CSF/AI RMF: governance and risk functions
  2. ODRL/PROV: authority, grounds and evidence
  3. GRC/IAM/BCM practice and NIST SP 800-34 for recovery
  4. NIST Cybersecurity Framework - Checked live (HTTP 200) on 2026-10-07.
  5. NIST SP 800-53A Rev. 5: Assessing Security and Privacy Controls - Checked live (HTTP 200) on 2026-10-07.
  6. W3C PROV-O: Provenance Ontology - Checked live (HTTP 200) on 2026-10-07.

Open questions

  • How to separate a finding from a risk and a task?
  • What does a sample prove?
  • How to close a finding after independent verification?
  • Установить границу и решение reuse/extend/new по действующим спецификациям.
  • Подтвердить semantic crosswalk, права и source mastership.
  • Выбрать immutable refs; провести проверки fixtures до заявления о публикационной готовности.

Machine files

Provenance

enterprise research programme · published-partial

Built from: enterprise/models/em-rsk-02/brief.json, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/em-rsk-02.json

Still in Russian: suggested owner, blocking decisions, vercy candidates. Translate in research/enterprise/i18n/units.en.json.