← Back to catalogue
Published

antilogism

vr.tr.antilogism · thing-antilogism

Let an agent explain the antilogism and its use in testing syllogisms, construct antilogisms from syllogisms, and describe its history and place in logic.

Thing Registry Cross-cutting context XCT.REL

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

4 bundles · 8 layers · 8 findings · 16 questions

Define What an antilogism is.

Definition

Definition.

Definition

Definition.

  1. What is an antilogism, and how does it relate to a valid syllogism? definition
  2. Why are the three propositions jointly inconsistent? definition

Construct

Constructing one.

Construct

Construction.

  1. How is the antilogism of this syllogism formed by negating the conclusion? action
  2. How is validity tested using the antilogism? action
Use Using antilogisms.

Test

Testing validity.

Test

Testing.

  1. Is this syllogism valid, judged by whether its antilogism is inconsistent? action
  2. How does the method handle existential import? boundary

Notation

Notation.

Notation

Notation.

  1. How are antilogisms written in class notation and Venn diagrams? definition
  2. How do they relate to modern predicate logic? definition
History Origins.

Ladd-Franklin

Christine Ladd-Franklin.

Ladd-Franklin

History.

  1. How did Christine Ladd-Franklin develop the antilogism, and how was it received? provenance
  2. Which sources document it? provenance

Place

Place in logic.

Place

Place in logic.

  1. How does the antilogism fit within the history of syllogistic and algebraic logic? provenance
  2. Which references are standard? provenance
Learn Teaching.

Teach

Teaching the antilogism.

Teach

Teaching.

  1. How can the antilogism be taught in introductory logic? action
  2. Which misconceptions arise? provenance

Exercises

Exercises.

Exercises

Exercises.

  1. Which exercises help practise antilogisms? action
  2. Which entry fits syllogisms? action

Classifiers Filled

Family
Thing Registry
Category
Cross-cutting context
Entry kind
noun.relation
Plane
XCT
Domain
XCT.REL
Facets: substance
abstract
Facets: origin
conceptual
Facets: agency
inert
Facets: mobility
not-applicable
Facets: scale
not-applicable
Facets: affordances
observable

What it is Filled

In logic, an inconsistent triad of propositions in which any two, taken as premises of a valid syllogism, imply the negation of the third, so that the three cannot all be true together; introduced by Christine Ladd-Franklin, the antilogism provides a test for the validity of syllogisms and a compact way to present syllogistic reasoning.

Why it exists Filled

Let an agent explain the antilogism and its use in testing syllogisms, construct antilogisms from syllogisms, and describe its history and place in logic.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • Inconsistent triad
  • Validity test
  • Ladd-Franklin origin
  • Syllogistic logic

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Present two contradictory propositions as an antilogism.
  • Apply antilogism tests to arguments that are not categorical syllogisms without noting the limit.
  • Use a formal flaw to dismiss a person's argument unfairly in a debate summary.

Only with a human decision

  • Using a formal logic verdict in grading or assessment of a person.

May

  • Test whether three propositions form an inconsistent triad and show the derived syllogisms.
  • Use an antilogism to check the validity of a categorical syllogism.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Logic tools can be misused to win arguments rather than find truth.
  • Students rely on correct explanations of formal methods.

Who is affected

  • Students and teachers
  • Participants in debates

Owners Filled

Steward

Nobody owns the concept; it belongs to logic and is held in common.

Links to other meta-models Filled

parent

  • oewn-13805250-n - registry parent class

related

  • logical relation - category
  • antecedent - propositional structure
  • homomorphism - formal structures contrast
  • scientific theory - reasoning about theories

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • Vercy registry: vr.tr.antilogism
  • Open English WordNet: oewn-92443234-n

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

Plane XCT: no invented physical properties.

Recognition optional Filled

  • Three mutually inconsistent propositions
  • Any two imply the negation of the third
  • A syllogism has two premises and a conclusion
  • Not physical; a triad of propositions.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • explain the antilogism
  • construct antilogisms from syllogisms
  • test validity
  • describe history

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Confusing antilogism with contradiction of two propositions
  • Misapplying to non-syllogistic arguments
  • Ignoring existential import issues

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • Logical notation conventions

Context of use required Filled

  • A test for syllogistic validity.
  • antilogisms for each valid syllogistic mood
  • antilogisms in class and set notation
  • antilogism as a proof technique
  • generalisations to other logics

Sources Filled

  1. Open English WordNet 2024, synset oewn-92443234-n - sense and gloss of the concept
  2. Wiktionary: antilogism - word senses and usage

Open questions

  • Should syllogism be the primary entry?
  • How should logic textbooks be linked?
  • How should historical sources be linked?

Machine files

Provenance

thing registry research (pass 2) · unreviewed

Built from: models/things/publications/thing-antilogism/spec.json