comparison
Let an agent make fair and useful comparisons, choose criteria, present similarities and differences clearly, and explain comparative constructions and figures of speech.
Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled
4 bundles · 8 layers · 8 findings · 16 questions
Make Making a comparison.
Criteria
Choosing criteria.
Criteria
Criteria.
- On which criteria should these things be compared, and are they comparable in kind? definition
- Which criteria matter most to the user? boundary
Present
Presenting.
Present
Presentation.
- How should the comparison be presented, as a table, prose or ranking? action
- Are similarities and differences both shown? boundary
Fair Fair comparison.
Bias
Bias and cherry-picking.
Bias
Bias.
- Does the comparison omit relevant criteria or use unequal data? boundary
- Are sources and dates consistent? boundary
Advertising
Comparative claims.
Advertising
Comparative claims.
- Does this comparative advertising claim meet legal rules on fairness and verifiability? provenance
- Which authority regulates it? provenance
Language Grammar and figures.
Grammar
Comparative forms.
Grammar
Comparative forms.
- How are comparatives and superlatives formed and used in this language? definition
- Which errors are common? provenance
Figurative
Simile and metaphor.
Figurative
Figurative comparison.
- Is this a simile, metaphor or analogy, and what does it convey? definition
- Does the imaginative comparison hold up? boundary
Science Comparative methods.
Methods
Comparative studies.
Methods
Methods.
- How are comparative studies designed to be valid? provenance
- Which confounders must be controlled? boundary
Decide
Comparison for decisions.
Decide
Decisions.
- How can a weighted comparison support this decision? action
- What are the trade-offs? definition
Classifiers Filled
- Family
- Thing Registry
- Category
- Cross-cutting context
- Entry kind
- noun.relation
- Plane
- XCT
- Domain
- XCT.REL
- Facets: substance
- abstract
- Facets: origin
- conceptual
- Facets: agency
- inert
- Facets: mobility
- not-applicable
- Facets: scale
- not-applicable
- Facets: affordances
- observable
- Other names and narrower kinds
- imaginative comparison
What it is Filled
A relation established by examining two or more things for their similarities and differences, in reasoning, language, science and everyday decisions, including grammatical comparison, analogies and imaginative comparisons such as similes and metaphors; comparisons require comparable criteria and can mislead when the things compared differ in kind.
Why it exists Filled
Let an agent make fair and useful comparisons, choose criteria, present similarities and differences clearly, and explain comparative constructions and figures of speech.
Distinguishing features Filled
- Relates two or more things
- Criteria-based
- Literal or figurative
- Basis for decisions
What robots and AI may and may not do Filled
Must not
- Choose criteria to favour one option while presenting the comparison as neutral.
- Compare people by ethnicity, religion or gender in ways that stereotype them.
- Use false analogies to mislead, such as likening a group of people to vermin.
- Hide a commercial interest behind a product comparison.
Only with a human decision
- Publishing comparisons that rank named people or businesses.
May
- Compare things on stated criteria, showing the data behind each judgement.
- Say when two things are not comparable on a given measure.
Moral aspects Filled
- Comparisons shape choices and reputations; slanted ones mislead.
- Comparing people can be a vehicle for prejudice.
Who is affected
- People and products compared
- Readers making decisions
Owners Filled
Steward
Nobody owns the concept; the author of a comparison answers for it.
Links to other meta-models Filled
parent
- oewn-00032220-n - registry parent class
related
- relation - category
- unrelatedness - absence of relation
- modification - comparative modifiers
- hypothesis - comparative testing
What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled
Identity and identifiers required Filled
- Vercy registry: vr.tr.comparison
- Open English WordNet: oewn-13876005-n
Direct properties not applicable Not applicable
Not applicable
Plane XCT: no invented physical properties.
Recognition optional Filled
- Similarities and differences
- Comparative and superlative forms
- Contrast emphasises differences only
- Not physical; relations, tables and figures of speech.
Capabilities and actions required Filled
- compare things on explicit criteria
- present comparisons in tables and prose
- explain comparative grammar
- explain similes, metaphors and analogies
Hazards and failure modes required Filled
- Comparing incomparable things
- Hidden or biased criteria
- Misleading comparisons in advertising
Standards and interfaces required Filled
- Rules on comparative advertising
- Methodological standards for comparative studies
Context of use required Filled
- Understanding and deciding by relating things.
- analytical comparisons
- comparative studies in science
- grammatical comparison
- figurative comparisons such as simile and metaphor
- analogies
Sources Filled
- Open English WordNet 2024, synset oewn-13876005-n - sense and gloss of the concept
- Wiktionary: comparison - word senses and usage
Open questions
- Should figurative comparison be a separate entry?
- How should comparative methods be linked?
- How should advertising rules be localised?
Machine files
Provenance
thing registry research (pass 2) · unreviewed
Built from: models/things/publications/thing-comparison/spec.json