← Back to catalogue
Published

contrary

vr.tr.contrary · thing-contrary

Let an agent explain the contrary relation in logic, distinguish it from contradiction, identify contraries of statements and terms, and support reasoning and teaching.

Thing Registry Cross-cutting context XCT.REL

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

4 bundles · 8 layers · 8 findings · 16 questions

Understand The relation.

Definition

Definition.

Definition

Definition.

  1. What makes two propositions contraries, and how does this differ from contradictories and subcontraries? definition
  2. Is the logical sense or the everyday sense of opposite meant? boundary

Square

Square of opposition.

Square

Square.

  1. How do contraries appear in the traditional square of opposition, and what happens with empty terms? definition
  2. Which entry fits the square of opposition? action
Apply Using contraries.

Identify

Identifying contraries.

Identify

Identification.

  1. What is a contrary of this statement, and could both statements be false? action
  2. Which errors are common? provenance

Dilemma

False dilemmas.

Dilemma

False dilemmas.

  1. How does confusing contraries with contradictories produce false dilemmas in argument? definition
  2. Which entry fits fallacies? action
Language Contrary terms.

Antonyms

Gradable antonyms.

Antonyms

Antonyms.

  1. How do contrary terms such as hot and cold differ from complementary antonyms such as alive and dead? definition
  2. Which entry fits antonymy? action

Usage

Everyday usage.

Usage

Usage.

  1. How is contrary used in everyday and legal language? definition
  2. How is it translated? action
Learn Theory and teaching.

Theory

Formal treatment.

Theory

Theory.

  1. How is contrariety treated in formal logic and semantics, and which references are standard? provenance
  2. Which entry fits formal semantics? action

Teach

Teaching.

Teach

Teaching.

  1. How can contraries and contradictories be taught with examples and diagrams? action
  2. Which misconceptions arise? provenance

Classifiers Filled

Family
Thing Registry
Category
Cross-cutting context
Entry kind
noun.relation
Plane
XCT
Domain
XCT.REL
Facets: substance
abstract
Facets: origin
conceptual
Facets: agency
inert
Facets: mobility
not-applicable
Facets: scale
not-applicable
Facets: affordances
observable

What it is Filled

In logic, the relation between two propositions that cannot both be true but can both be false, as between the universal affirmative and universal negative in the traditional square of opposition or between statements such as all are red and none are red; contraries differ from contradictories, of which exactly one must be true, and the term also describes opposite terms such as hot and cold that admit intermediates.

Why it exists Filled

Let an agent explain the contrary relation in logic, distinguish it from contradiction, identify contraries of statements and terms, and support reasoning and teaching.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • Exclusive but not exhaustive
  • Square of opposition
  • Gradable opposites
  • Common reasoning error

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Treat two contraries as if one must be true.
  • Build or endorse false dilemmas from contrary options.
  • Confuse the logical sense of contrary with everyday disagreement.

Only with a human decision

  • Grading a learner's formal logic work where the classification is disputed.

May

  • Identify contrary pairs in the square of opposition and explain how they differ from contradictories.
  • Point out when an argument treats contraries as the only options.

Moral aspects Filled

  • False dilemmas built from contraries push people into choices that are not forced.

Who is affected

  • Students of logic
  • Audiences of arguments

Owners Filled

Steward

Nobody owns the concept; it is held in common by logic.

Links to other meta-models Filled

parent

  • oewn-13805250-n - registry parent class

related

  • logical relation - category
  • contradictory - the neighbouring opposition
  • antonymy - contrary terms in language
  • difference - a broader relation

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • Vercy registry: vr.tr.contrary
  • Open English WordNet: oewn-13805633-n

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

Plane XCT: no invented physical properties.

Recognition optional Filled

  • Both cannot be true, both can be false
  • Universal affirmative and negative
  • Contradictories cannot both be false
  • Not physical; a logical relation.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • explain the relation
  • distinguish from contradiction
  • identify contraries
  • support reasoning

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Treating contraries as contradictories
  • False dilemmas
  • Confusing logical and everyday senses

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • Conventions of formal logic
  • No regulation

Context of use required Filled

  • Propositions that cannot both be true.
  • contraries in the square of opposition
  • contrary propositions in general
  • contrary terms and gradable antonyms
  • subcontraries as the dual relation

Sources Filled

  1. Open English WordNet 2024, synset oewn-13805633-n - sense and gloss of the concept
  2. Wiktionary: contrary - word senses and usage

Open questions

  • Should the square of opposition be a separate entry?
  • How should logic textbooks be linked?
  • How should linguistic antonymy be linked?

Machine files

Provenance

thing registry research (pass 2) · unreviewed

Built from: models/things/publications/thing-contrary/spec.json