← Back to catalogue
Published

standing stone

vr.tr.standing-stone · thing-q2330559

Let an agent explain standing stones, relay forms, dating, purposes and heritage from archaeology sources with interpretations attributed, describe examples and flag the loosely filed alias, and distinguish menhirs from stone circles, dolmens, natural rocks and modern markers.

Thing Registry Physical world and living systems PHY.BLT

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

4 bundles · 8 layers · 8 findings · 16 questions

Understand What a standing stone is.

Definition

Definition.

Definition

Definition.

  1. What is a standing stone or menhir, and how does it differ from stone circles, dolmens, natural rocks and modern markers? definition
  2. Is someone visiting a protected monument, which should not be damaged or climbed where prohibited? boundary

Alias

Rubbing stone.

Alias

Alias.

  1. Why is a livestock rubbing stone a different object? definition
  2. Which entry fits the specific stone? action
Archaeology Archaeology.

Dating

Dating.

Dating

Dating.

  1. How are standing stones dated? provenance
  2. Which references are standard? provenance

Forms

Forms.

Forms

Forms.

  1. What are single menhirs, alignments and statue menhirs? provenance
  2. Which sources are cited? provenance
Purpose Purpose.

Interpretations

Interpretations.

Interpretations

Interpretations.

  1. What purposes do archaeologists propose, and why are they uncertain, with positions attributed? provenance
  2. Is the presentation neutral and attributed? boundary

Astronomy

Astronomical claims.

Astronomy

Astronomy.

  1. How are astronomical alignments argued and debated, with positions attributed? provenance
  2. Is the presentation neutral and attributed? boundary
Context Heritage.

Examples

Notable examples.

Examples

Examples.

  1. What are Carnac, Callanish and other notable standing stones? provenance
  2. Which entry fits Carnac stones? action

Protection

Protection.

Protection

Protection.

  1. How are standing stones protected as heritage? provenance
  2. Is the information current? boundary

Classifiers Filled

Family
Thing Registry
Category
Physical world and living systems
Entry kind
thing
Plane
PHY
Domain
PHY.BLT
Other names and narrower kinds
Rubbing stone

What it is Filled

A large upright stone set in the ground by people, a menhir or standing stone, erected in many cultures from the Neolithic and Bronze Age onward as single stones, alignments or parts of stone circles, for ceremonial, funerary, astronomical or territorial purposes that are often uncertain; the registry alias rubbing stone names a stone used by livestock to scratch against, a different, non-monumental object that appears loosely filed. Standing stones such as those at Carnac and Callanish are protected heritage, and interpretations of their purpose are debated, with positions attributed.

Why it exists Filled

Let an agent explain standing stones, relay forms, dating, purposes and heritage from archaeology sources with interpretations attributed, describe examples and flag the loosely filed alias, and distinguish menhirs from stone circles, dolmens, natural rocks and modern markers.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • Upright placed stone
  • Prehistoric
  • Single, rows or circles
  • Uncertain purpose

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Present speculative purposes such as energy lines or astronomy as established fact.
  • Direct people to climb, move, mark or dig around protected stones.
  • Reveal locations of unrecorded or vulnerable sites to people likely to damage them.
  • Treat stones that are sacred to living communities as mere curiosities.

Only with a human decision

  • Any work, survey or excavation at a standing stone.

May

  • Describe standing stones from archaeological sources, stating which purposes are known and which are speculative.
  • Report damage to a protected monument to the heritage authority.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Standing stones are irreplaceable heritage and some remain sacred.
  • Speculation presented as fact misleads visitors and learners.

Who is affected

  • Local and descendant communities
  • Landowners
  • Future visitors

Owners Filled

Steward

The landowner where the stone stands; heritage authorities protect scheduled monuments.

Master systems

  • National heritage monument registers

Links to other meta-models Filled

parent

  • Q24590007 - registry parent class

related

  • megalith - related
  • stone circle
  • dolmen
  • rubbing stone - loosely filed alias

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • Vercy registry: vr.tr.standing-stone
  • Wikidata: Q2330559 (https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2330559)

Direct properties required Filled

  • period: Neolithic and Bronze Age onward note
  • examples: Carnac, Callanish list
  • registry parent: raised stone note

Recognition required Filled

  • Upright stone erected by people
  • Rubbing stone
  • Stone circles arrange many stones; dolmens are chambered tombs; natural rocks are not placed; modern markers are recent
  • Tall upright stones standing alone or in rows and circles in the landscape.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • explain forms and dating
  • relay purposes with attribution
  • flag the loosely filed alias
  • distinguish related monuments

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Presenting speculative purposes as fact
  • Damage to protected monuments
  • Loosely filed non-monument alias

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • Heritage protection laws for monuments
  • Rules against damaging scheduled monuments

Context of use required Filled

  • Prehistoric upright stone monuments.
  • single menhirs
  • stone rows and alignments
  • stone circles
  • statue menhirs

Sources Filled

  1. Wikidata item Q2330559: standing stone - identity and sense of the item
  2. Menhir - An upright standing stone erected as a prehistoric monument.

Open questions

  • The registry alias rubbing stone should be reviewed as a different object
  • Should stone circles be a separate entry?
  • How should heritage listings be linked?

Machine files

Provenance

thing registry research (pass 2) · unreviewed

Built from: models/things/publications/thing-q2330559/spec.json