← Back to catalogue
Published

Public Consultation

vr.wm-act-041 · wm-act-041-public-consultation

Describe one identifiable public consultation process and the evidence connecting its invitation, received input, consideration and response.

World Models Activities and processes ACT.CIV

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

3 bundles · 3 layers · 5 findings · 12 questions

Proposal and scope What is being consulted on, by whom and within which limits.

Consultation notice

The published notice, proposal documents and the questions put to the public.

Consulting body and proposal

The body that consults and the proposal it puts forward, with its legal basis.

  1. Which public body runs the consultation, and under which legal or policy basis?
  2. Which proposal and supporting documents were published for comment?

Consultation window

The opening and closing dates and how they were announced.

  1. When did the consultation open and close, and was the period extended?
  2. Through which channels was the consultation announced to the affected public?
Participation Who took part and what they said.

Submissions

Responses received, their channel and how they are recorded.

Submission record

Each response with its date, channel and the respondent category it declares.

  1. How many submissions arrived, through which channels, and before the deadline?
  2. Did the respondent agree to publication of the submission and of their name?
  3. Were coordinated or duplicate campaign responses identified and handled openly?

Reach and accessibility

Whether affected groups could take part.

  1. Which affected groups were invited or reached, and which were not?
  2. Were documents and channels accessible in the languages and formats people needed?
Response How the input was considered and reported back.

Consultation response

The published summary of input and the body's answer to it.

Response document

A summary of the main points and the body's stated reaction to each.

  1. Was a response published, and when relative to the close of consultation?
  2. Which changes to the proposal does the response attribute to the input received?
  3. Which significant points were rejected, and with what reasons?

Classifiers Filled

Family
World Models
Category
Activities and processes
Entry kind
entity
Navigation path
NAV.ACT.CIV
Domain
ACT.CIV
Industry
Cross-industry
Tags
publicconsultationact.civ

What it is Filled

A public consultation is a time-bounded process in which a public body puts a proposal before the public or defined stakeholders, collects their submissions and publishes a response stating how the input was considered. It ends with the response, not with the decision on the proposal; elections, referendums and private market research are outside it.

In scope

  • Consultation identity, authority references, issue and proposal versions, notice and participation arrangements
  • Submission receipt and handling assertions, scoped participant references, traceable analysis and response evidence
  • Consultation-specific lifecycle, quality, accessibility, privacy, access and record continuity

Out of scope

  • Authority, person, organization, policy proposal, legislation and final decision masters
  • Elections, binding votes, petitions, advocacy campaigns and private market research as separate processes; surveys and hearings may be consultation methods
  • Executing publication, sending submissions, identity verification, legal adjudication, automated exclusion, binding decisions or downstream implementation

Why it exists Filled

Describe one identifiable public consultation process and the evidence connecting its invitation, received input, consideration and response.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • A public consultation gathers views on a proposal; it does not decide, unlike a vote, referendum or approval.
  • It is run by a public body with a published notice, a defined window and a duty or practice of responding.
  • Distinct from a campaign, its parent, because its purpose is to receive input, not to persuade.
  • Distinct from surveys and market research, which sample opinion without a proposal open to formal comment.

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Generate or submit responses in the names of people who did not write or approve them.
  • Flood a consultation with automated or duplicate submissions to inflate a position.
  • Publish respondents' names or personal details without their consent.
  • Drop or misclassify submissions so that a summary misrepresents the input.
  • Present a consultation summary as the final decision on the proposal.

Only with a human decision

  • Sending a submission on someone's behalf.
  • Approving the published response of the consulting body.
  • Deciding to exclude submissions as abusive or out of scope.

May

  • Find and summarize open consultations and their deadlines for a user.
  • Help a person draft their own submission in their own words and send it only with their approval.
  • Analyse submissions by theme for the consulting body, keeping counts and categories traceable to the records.
  • Compare a published response with the submissions it claims to summarize.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Consultation is a channel of democratic participation; fake or mass-generated input distorts it.
  • Respondents may reveal political views or personal circumstances and must control their publication.
  • Groups without time, language or digital access can be left out unless the process reaches them.

Who is affected

  • Members of the public who respond
  • Communities affected by the proposal
  • Public bodies running consultations
  • Organised interest groups

Owners Filled

Steward

The public body that runs the consultation owns its notice, submissions record and response.

Roles

Process steward
Maintain mandate, window evidence and profile bindings.
Intake custodian
Index receipts and safeguard restricted original material.
Analysis reviewer
Review coding, exclusions, counts and contrary evidence.
Response approver
Approve response meaning and authorized release scope.
Privacy and records steward
Assess disclosure, retention, rights requests and disposition authority.
Public reader
Read approved public projections without access to restricted identities.

Master systems

  • Government consultation portals
  • Legislative and regulatory dockets

Links to other meta-models Filled

aligned

  • WM-ACT-028 Campaign - Candidate parent alignment only; consultation outreach can reference a campaign without inheriting persuasion or campaign operations.
  • PROV-O - Conceptual attribution and derivation mapping only; executable mapping and conformance are deferred.

references

  • Public authority master - Bind the initiating authority and asserted competence through a profile; do not reproduce its institutional lifecycle.
  • Proposal and policy document master - Pin consulted and later proposal revisions without mutating their masters.
  • Person and organization masters - Optional restricted participant and representative references; anonymous input remains possible under the profile.
  • Decision / Approval Record - Optional final decision reference, separate from the consultation response and closure state.

neighbor

  • WM-ACT-028 Campaign - Registry parent is a candidate ALIGN only. A consultation elicits input; an outreach campaign may assist it but its persuasion goals and lifecycle are external. No campaign inheritance is ratified.
  • Proposal, authority and participant master records - Carry versioned references and locally asserted roles only. A consultation does not own the proposal, institutional competence or a person identity, and steward custody does not transfer respondent rights.
  • Decision / Approval Record and administrative case - Optional separately mastered references. A consultation response can explain treatment of input without being the final decision; an unanswered consultation remains representable.
  • Survey, hearing, petition and deliberative assembly - A survey or hearing may be a channel within this instance. A petition or representative deliberative process has an external root; method overlap does not establish equivalence or representativeness.

parent

  • WM-ACT-028

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • A consultation is identified by the consulting body and its own reference or docket number.
  • Submissions are identified by a reference issued by the consultation portal or body.

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

A public consultation is an institutional process, not a physical object with measurable physical properties.

Recognition optional Filled

  • A notice inviting comment on a named proposal, with a closing date and a way to respond.
  • Often confused with a petition, a referendum, an opinion poll or a public hearing.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • A consultation can be opened, extended, closed and answered with a published response.
  • Submissions can be received, acknowledged, published with consent and analysed by theme.

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Astroturfing and automated submissions that fake public opinion.
  • Exposure of respondents' identities or views without consent.
  • Consultation used as a formality after the decision was already taken.

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • Online consultation portals with submission forms and document downloads.
  • Regulatory docket systems where comments are filed against a proposal.
  • Published response documents and summaries of submissions.

Context of use required Filled

  • Required by law for many planning, environmental and regulatory proposals.
  • The Aarhus Convention gives the public a right to participate in environmental decisions.

Sources Filled

  1. Consultation principles - Cabinet Office
  2. OECD Guidelines for Citizen Participation Processes - planning, implementing and evaluating - Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
  3. Public participation under the Aarhus Convention - United Nations Economic Commission for Europe
  4. United States Code, Title 5, section 553 - Rule making - United States Government Publishing Office
  5. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2 - World Wide Web Consortium
  6. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 - European Parliament and Council of the European Union
  7. PROV-O: The PROV Ontology - World Wide Web Consortium
  8. Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters (Aarhus Convention), UNECE
  9. OECD Recommendation of the Council on Open Government, OECD

Open questions

  • Verify current authoritative source versions, the full environmental participation text and jurisdiction-specific applicability and exceptions.
  • Develop nested instance schemas and tested mappings using cancelled, reopened, unanswered, anonymous, late, campaign, contested-exclusion and lawful-erasure examples.
  • Restore independent external review and close all holds before canonical or publishable-draft promotion.
  • Independent external review is absent under the waiver.
  • Direct HTTP status and current-version verification are incomplete; UNECE full retrieval failed.
  • Nested instance validation, tested accessibility, provenance mappings and pinned neighbor bindings are not implemented.
  • Domestic consultation rights, remedies, language obligations, licensing and disclosure/retention regimes require qualified profile review.

Machine files

Provenance

world-models research · reviewable-draft

Built from: models/wm-act-041-public-consultation/spec.yaml, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/wm-act-041-public-consultation.json