Biological Pathway / Process
Represent a reusable, evidence-qualified molecular or cellular process description with explicit context and exchange limits.
Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled
3 bundles · 4 layers · 5 findings · 10 questions
Pathway identity Which process is described and for which organisms.
Definition and scope
The process the pathway represents and its taxonomic scope.
Pathway reference
The pathway with its database identifier, name and version.
- Which pathway database and identifier define this pathway?
- Which version or release of the pathway is used?
Taxonomic scope
The organisms for which the pathway is curated or inferred.
- For which species is the pathway curated?
- Was it inferred from another species by orthology, and from which?
Pathway content The participants and steps that make up the process.
Participants
Genes, proteins, complexes and small molecules in the pathway.
Participant list
Each participant with its identifier in a reference database.
- Which genes, proteins and metabolites take part, by reference identifier?
- Are participants given as specific forms, such as modified proteins or complexes?
Reactions and regulation
The steps, their order and the regulation acting on them.
Reaction steps
Reactions or interactions with inputs, outputs, catalysts and regulators.
- Which reactions make up the pathway, and in what order?
- Which participants catalyse or regulate each step?
Evidence How the pathway knowledge is supported.
Curation and evidence
The literature and experimental evidence behind each step.
Supporting evidence
The publications and evidence codes that support each step.
- Which publications support each step, and with what kind of evidence?
- Who curated the pathway, and when was it last reviewed?
Classifiers Filled
- Family
- World Models
- Category
- Physical world and living systems
- Entry kind
- pattern
- Navigation path
- NAV.PHY.LIV.MOL
- Domain
- PHY.LIV.MOL
- Industry
- Cross-industry
- Tags
- biologicalpathwayprocessphy.liv.mol
What it is Filled
A biological pathway is a reusable description of a molecular or cellular process: an ordered set of reactions, interactions and regulatory steps among genes, proteins and small molecules that produce a biological function. It is a curated model of how a process works in a taxon, not a measurement in one sample and not the whole organism.
In scope
- Stable pathway identity, scope, classification and versioned external mappings.
- Context-qualified participant roles, steps, regulatory assertions and topology.
- Claim-level evidence, inference lineage, contradictory assertions and local curation lifecycle.
- Declared data projections, validation limitations and references to observations or computational models.
Out of scope
- Organism, taxon, gene, biomolecule, disease, phenotype and specimen master lifecycles.
- Actual biological occurrences, raw measurements, clinical conclusions, experimental protocols and intervention execution.
- Simulation algorithms, kinetic parameter fitting, enrichment execution and automatic causal discovery.
- Operational instructions involving harmful biological agents or controlled materials; only access and review policy is represented.
Why it exists Filled
Represent a reusable, evidence-qualified molecular or cellular process description with explicit context and exchange limits.
Distinguishing features Filled
- It is a curated, reusable model of a process, not an observation in a single sample or experiment.
- It connects many genes, proteins and metabolites; a single gene or protein has its own model.
- Phenotypes and diseases may result from pathway changes but are described in their own models.
- Its taxonomic scope must be stated, because pathways are often inferred across species.
What robots and AI may and may not do Filled
Must not
- Present an inferred pathway as experimentally established for the species.
- Merge pathways from different databases without keeping their identifiers and versions.
- Give guidance for enhancing the harmfulness or transmissibility of pathogens.
- Use pathway analysis results as a clinical diagnosis.
- Strip curator attribution or licence terms from pathway data.
Only with a human decision
- Using pathway analysis to support a clinical or regulatory decision.
- Publishing a new or changed curated pathway.
- Resolving conflicting evidence between curation sources.
May
- Look up pathways and their participants by reference identifiers.
- Map experimental results onto pathways for interpretation.
- Report which steps of a pathway are supported by which evidence.
- Flag pathways inferred by orthology rather than curated for the species.
Moral aspects Filled
- Pathway knowledge drives drug discovery, and errors can mislead research for years.
- Some pathway knowledge on pathogens is dual-use and needs responsible handling.
- Curators' work should be credited and licences respected.
Who is affected
- Researchers and curators
- Patients affected by research based on pathway models
- Pathway database maintainers
Owners Filled
Steward
A curated pathway knowledge base or research consortium that maintains the pathway and its evidence.
Roles
- Scientific steward
- Own scope, namespace and local review policy.
- Pathway curator
- Propose evidence-qualified assertions and changes within assigned scope.
- Scientific reviewer
- Assess disputed claims and semantic mapping losses; record unresolved limitations.
- Evidence custodian
- Manage permissions, source terms, restricted payloads and retention execution.
- Read-only consumer
- Use qualified projections without upgrading inference to occurrence or clinical conclusion.
Master systems
- Curated pathway databases
- Gene and protein reference databases
Links to other meta-models Filled
references
- WM-LIV-001 - Candidate taxon binding; preserve source taxonomy version and external authority.
- WM-LIV-002 - Optional organism context for linked observations only. Reject registry parent as biological inheritance.
- WM-LIV-013 - Candidate gene reference; gene identity is not protein identity.
- WM-LIV-014 - Candidate biomolecule master binding; own only local participation qualifiers.
- WM-LIV-015 - Optional evidence-qualified phenotype association with no trait master duplication.
- WM-LIV-021 - Optional biological condition context; no diagnostic conclusion or condition lifecycle.
- WM-LIV-023 - Optional source specimen reference; no sample custody or measurement execution.
aligned
- BioPAX Level 3 - Conceptual exchange alignment only; complete ontology and mapping validation remain held.
- GO-CAM and GO annotations - Preserve typed activity and classification assertions; mapping need not be lossless.
- SBML Level 3 Version 2 Core Release 2 - Separate computational model profile with declared packages and missing assumptions; no automatic executable conversion.
- PROV-O - Proposed curation provenance alignment; no full provenance conformance claim.
neighbor
- WM-LIV-002 Organism Individual - Registry parent_ids is a candidate navigation link, not accepted inheritance: a reusable process description is not an organism individual. Optional occurrence context must reference an external organism master.
- WM-LIV-001 Taxon - Reference a versioned taxon assertion and inference scope; do not create or govern taxonomy here.
- WM-LIV-013 Gene / Genomic Feature and WM-LIV-014 Protein / Biomolecule - Own participation and contextual form references only. A gene reference is not the same biological identity as its product; sequence and molecule masters remain external.
- WM-LIV-015 Phenotype / Trait and WM-LIV-021 Disease / Biological Condition - Contextual associations require evidence and relation type. Pathway presence or association does not establish a phenotype or diagnosis.
- WM-LIV-023 Clinical / Biological Specimen and external analysis models - Evidence can refer to specimen, dataset or analysis identifiers; sampling, raw data and analysis execution are not owned by this pattern.
- Biological process ontology class and process occurrence - A vocabulary term classifies a pattern; a diagram projects it; an occurrence realizes it under circumstances. These identifiers are not interchangeable.
parent
- WM-LIV-002
What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled
Identity and identifiers required Filled
- A pathway is identified by its stable identifier in a pathway database, with version.
- Participants are identified by reference identifiers such as gene, protein and chemical entity identifiers.
- Process terms can be mapped to Gene Ontology biological process terms.
Direct properties not applicable Not applicable
Not applicable
A pathway is an abstract model of a process, not a physical object with measurable properties.
Recognition optional Filled
- A pathway record names a process, a set of participants with identifiers and a taxonomic scope.
- Often confused with a gene set without reactions, or with an interaction network without order.
Capabilities and actions required Filled
- Pathways can be queried by participant, process term or species.
- Experimental data can be overlaid on pathways for enrichment analysis.
- Pathways can be exchanged between tools in standard formats.
Hazards and failure modes required Filled
- Misinterpretation of enrichment results as causal evidence.
- Propagation of errors from inferred pathways into downstream research.
- Dual-use misuse of pathogen pathway knowledge.
Standards and interfaces required Filled
- BioPAX for pathway data exchange.
- Systems Biology Markup Language (SBML) for computational models.
- Gene Ontology for biological process terms.
Context of use required Filled
- Used in molecular biology, systems biology, drug discovery and the interpretation of omics data.
- Pathway knowledge is curated in public databases with their own licences.
Sources Filled
- Reactome Data Model - Reactome scientific consortium
- Explain the identifiers associated with entities and events - Reactome scientific consortium
- Introduction to GO annotations - Gene Ontology Consortium
- GO-CAM overview - Gene Ontology Consortium
- Guide to GO evidence codes - Gene Ontology Consortium
- BioPAX Level 3 OWLdoc - string annotations - BioPAX community
- BioPAX Level 3 - Conversion - BioPAX community
- SBML Level 3 Version 2 - SBML community
- PROV-O: The PROV Ontology - World Wide Web Consortium
- Gene Ontology, Gene Ontology Consortium
- BioPAX Biological Pathway Exchange, BioPAX community
- Reactome pathway knowledgebase
Open questions
- Run the coordinator HTTP checker and verify exact source releases, ontology files, relevant normative specifications and source-use terms before closing the source hold.
- Develop instance and exchange fixtures covering partial pathways, cycles, unknown coefficients, alternative sets, explicit negation, conflicting context and loss of evidence during projection.
- Pin neighbor schemas and obtain qualified scientific and governance profile review without importing external master lifecycles.
- Restore independent external review before canonical or publishable-draft promotion.
- Independent external provider review is absent; the later local no-tools audit cannot replace it.
- Direct HTTP checks are unattempted under the owner-reported sandbox restriction. Browser content access is not a measured HTTP status, hash or verified current release.
- BioPAX ontology serialization was not readable through the browser; selected Level 3 generated documentation was used instead. SBML support is limited to the version landing page, not its full normative text.
- Nested executable instance schemas, validator fixtures, complete controlled-vocabulary pins and loss-tested exchange bindings remain future profile work.
- Scientific scope, rights, retention, sensitive data and restricted biological-use profiles require qualified adoption review. No clinical validation or universal pathway coverage is asserted.
Machine files
Provenance
world-models research · reviewable-draft
Built from: models/wm-liv-016-biological-pathway-process/spec.yaml, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/wm-liv-016-biological-pathway-process.json