← Back to catalogue
Published

Conservation Status Assessment

vr.wm-liv-022 · wm-liv-022-conservation-status-assessment

Preserve one attributable, versioned conservation assessment with its subject, scope, method, evidence, result and review history.

World Models Physical world and living systems PHY.LIV.CNS

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

3 bundles · 4 layers · 5 findings · 10 questions

Assessment frame What was assessed, where, by whom and under which rules.

Scope and authority

The assessed unit, region and responsible authority.

Assessed unit

The taxon or unit assessed with its taxonomic concept and region.

  1. Which taxon, population or habitat was assessed, under which taxonomic concept?
  2. Is the assessment global, regional or national?

Criteria and authority

The scheme, version and responsible assessors.

  1. Which categories and criteria, in which version, were applied?
  2. Which authority or body assessed and reviewed it?
Evidence and result The data and the category assigned.

Evidence

Population, range and threat data used.

Supporting data

The quantitative and qualitative evidence for each criterion.

  1. Which data on population size, trend and range were used, and from which dates?
  2. Which threats were identified, and how certain is the evidence?

Category

The category and criteria met.

Assigned category

The category with the criteria codes met and the justification.

  1. Which category was assigned, and which criteria were met?
  2. Is the taxon data deficient, or was the category inferred?
Versioning How the assessment changes over time.

Assessment history

Previous assessments and reasons for change.

Change of category

A change between assessments and whether it is genuine.

  1. What was the previous category, and when was it assessed?
  2. Is the change genuine or due to new information or taxonomic change?

Classifiers Filled

Family
World Models
Category
Physical world and living systems
Entry kind
entity
Navigation path
NAV.PHY.LIV.CNS
Domain
PHY.LIV.CNS
Industry
Cross-industry
Tags
conservationstatusassessmentphy.liv.cns

What it is Filled

A conservation status assessment is a versioned, evidence-based judgement by a named authority of how threatened a taxon, population or habitat is in a given area, expressed as a category under a stated set of criteria such as a red list. It is a dated assessment, not the taxon itself, and differs from legal protection, which a status may inform but does not grant.

In scope

  • Assessment identifier and revision, assessed-unit reference, spatial scope, dates and scheme binding.
  • Evidence selections, criterion or parameter evaluations, uncertainty, attributed conclusions and review references.
  • Local workflow, correction and reassessment links, bounded publication projections and downstream-use qualifications.

Out of scope

  • Taxonomic naming and circumscription authority, population census execution, habitat and ecosystem master lifecycles.
  • Universal category calculator, extinction declaration authority, recovery scoring, legal protection, trade restriction or harvest authorization.
  • Conservation intervention execution, funding priority optimization, multi-assessment indices and automated ecological trend inference.
  • External registry writes, source-record alteration, generic identity or provenance infrastructure and operational compliance certification.

Why it exists Filled

Preserve one attributable, versioned conservation assessment with its subject, scope, method, evidence, result and review history.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • A dated judgement about a taxon or habitat, not the taxon itself or its occurrence records.
  • Always tied to a named scheme, version, region and assessing authority.
  • Differs from legal protection status, which a law grants and which may differ from the assessed category.
  • Changes between versions can be genuine or non-genuine, and this distinction is part of the record.

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Assign or publish a conservation category on its own authority.
  • Mix categories from different schemes or regions without labelling them.
  • Treat an assessed category as legal protection status.
  • Disclose sensitive locations of threatened species gathered as evidence.
  • Drop the uncertainty or data-deficient flag when reporting a category.

Only with a human decision

  • Approving and publishing an assessment.
  • Using an assessment to set legal protection or harvest quotas.

May

  • Retrieve the current and past categories of a taxon with scheme, region and date.
  • Compile evidence for assessors from occurrence and monitoring data.
  • Report when an assessment is older than the scheme's recommended reassessment interval.
  • Flag inconsistencies between global and regional assessments.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Categories steer conservation money and legal protection, so bias or error has real consequences for species.
  • Assessments can affect livelihoods of people who use the species or its land.
  • Data-poor species and regions risk being overlooked.

Who is affected

  • Assessed species and their habitats
  • Communities that use or live alongside the species
  • Assessors and conservation authorities

Owners Filled

Steward

The red list authority or conservation body that conducts, reviews and publishes assessments for its scheme and region.

Roles

Assessment steward
Maintain identity, profile bindings and source rights without claiming taxonomic authority.
Assessor
Supply documented evaluations and uncertainty within an evidenced mandate.
Reviewer
Inspect evidence, conflicts, comparability and unresolved criteria; record an attributed disposition.
Release authority
Approve a specified assessment revision under the adopting procedure; external publication requires its own evidence.
Disclosure custodian
Authorize audience-specific views, sensitivity review and retention decisions.
Consumer
Respect scope, scheme, date, uncertainty, source rights and use limitations.

Master systems

  • Global red list database
  • National red list register

Links to other meta-models Filled

references

  • WM-LIV-001 - Taxon concept when the assessed subject is a taxon. Qualifies the registry parent as subject reference, not inheritance. Target binding requires a pinned specification.
  • WM-LIV-003 - Population subject when the scheme permits; do not own census or population lifecycle.
  • WM-LIV-006 - Ecosystem subject alternative under a compatible scheme; no species-category coercion.
  • WM-LIV-010 - Habitat subject alternative with external classification and region binding.
  • WM-MAT-008 - Qualified observations and measurements retained in their external master.
  • WM-KNW-018 - Assessment scheme and category vocabulary reference; a scheme binding is mandatory semantically but this registry implementation is not required.

aligned

  • Darwin Core - Conceptual taxon, occurrence and disclosure metadata mapping; no conformance claim.
  • PROV-O - Conceptual attributed evidence and revision links; no provenance engine is supplied.

neighbor

  • WM-LIV-001 Taxon - Registry parent is interpreted as subject reference, not inheritance: an assessment is not a taxon. Preserve the assessed concept version rather than merging by name.
  • WM-LIV-003 Population; WM-LIV-006 Ecosystem / Biome; WM-LIV-010 Habitat - Conditional assessed-unit alternatives require an explicit scheme profile and external concept reference. A habitat is not forced into a taxon identifier.
  • WM-MAT-008 Observation / Measurement Record - Reference source observations and imported qualified estimates. Local evidence selection does not own observation collection, instrument control or the raw-data master.
  • WM-KNW-018 Taxonomy / Classification Scheme - Bind to the criteria edition and vocabulary namespace; do not define a universal risk ladder or silently map categories between schemes.
  • Legal designation and conservation action - A scientific or reporting assessment may inform separate decisions. Recording a result does not itself grant protection, prohibit use or authorize action.
  • Recovery assessment and aggregate index - Recovery measures and portfolio trends need separate methods and records. Category changes alone are not a verified ecological trend.

parent

  • WM-LIV-001

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • Identified by the publishing authority's assessment identifier, the taxon identifier and the assessment year or version.
  • The taxon is referenced by its accepted name and a taxonomic database identifier.

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

The subject is an institutional or informational record with no physical quantities of its own.

Recognition optional Filled

  • Marked by a category code, the criteria met, an assessment date, a region and the assessors.
  • Often confused with a legal protection listing, a trade restriction listing or a population estimate.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • Is versioned by reassessment, with reasons for any category change.
  • Can be aggregated into indices of trends across many taxa.

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Outdated assessments that hide recent decline.
  • Disclosure of locations of rare species to collectors.

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria and its regional application guidelines.
  • Taxonomic name services for linking assessments to taxa.
  • National reporting under biodiversity conventions and directives.

Context of use required Filled

  • Used in conservation planning, impact assessment and biodiversity reporting.
  • Assessments exist at global, regional and national levels with different authorities.

Sources Filled

  1. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species - conservation tool overview - International Union for Conservation of Nature
  2. Regional assessments - International Union for Conservation of Nature
  3. Assessment process - International Union for Conservation of Nature
  4. Reasons for changing category - International Union for Conservation of Nature
  5. Conservation Status Assessments: Methodology for Assigning Ranks - NatureServe
  6. Conservation Status Categories - NatureServe
  7. Reporting under Article 17 of the Habitats Directive - European Environment Agency
  8. Current Best Practices for Generalizing Sensitive Species Occurrence Data - Global Biodiversity Information Facility
  9. Darwin Core Quick Reference Guide - Biodiversity Information Standards (TDWG)
  10. PROV-O: The PROV Ontology - World Wide Web Consortium
  11. IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria, Version 3.1, International Union for Conservation of Nature
  12. Guidelines for Application of IUCN Red List Criteria at Regional and National Levels, International Union for Conservation of Nature
  13. Convention on Biological Diversity, United Nations

Open questions

  • Retrieve and pin the full current criteria, regional and procedural guidance for each adopted scheme; run the prepared source checker and independently verify claim support and reuse rights.
  • Build conditional subject profiles, nested data schemas and mappings with cases for concept splits, missing estimates, range ranks, differing regions, challenges and genuine versus non-genuine change.
  • Test audience-specific evidence projections against location inference and retention cases, with qualified approval and community knowledge protocols where relevant.
  • Restore independent external review before any canonical or publishable-draft promotion.
  • Current full IUCN criteria, regional adjustment guidance and process versions were not retrieved; no detailed threshold implementation is admitted.
  • NatureServe 2012 and EEA overview are scoped examples; contemporary calculators, reporting matrices and all scheme-specific exceptions remain unverified.
  • Nested data-element schemas, executable acceptance fixtures, precision policies and pinned neighboring-model bindings remain to be built.
  • Recovery metrics, ecosystem collapse frameworks beyond the admitted examples, indigenous knowledge protocols and global scheme coverage require separate profile research.
  • Source license validation and independent external review remain open.

Machine files

Provenance

world-models research · reviewable-draft

Built from: models/wm-liv-022-conservation-status-assessment/spec.yaml, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/wm-liv-022-conservation-status-assessment.json