← Back to catalogue
Published

Sanction / Sentence

vr.wm-pol-022 · wm-pol-022-sanction-sentence

Describe one imposed legal consequence, its qualified terms and evidence of its execution lifecycle.

World Models Society, people and institutions SOC.POL.SAN

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

3 bundles · 3 layers · 5 findings · 11 questions

Imposition What was imposed, by whom and on what basis.

Imposed terms

The sanction type, terms and the decision it comes from.

Source decision

The sanction traces to a decision of a competent authority and its legal basis.

  1. Which decision imposed the sanction, and which authority issued it?
  2. Is the decision final or still open to appeal?

Sanction terms

Type, amount or duration, conditions and any suspension.

  1. What type of sanction was imposed, with which amount, duration or conditions?
  2. Is any part of the sanction suspended or conditional?
Execution How the sanction is carried out.

Execution lifecycle

Start, progress, modification and completion.

Execution status

Execution is tracked with its start, credits and current state.

  1. Has execution started, and on what date?
  2. Which credits, such as time already served or payments made, apply?
  3. Has the sanction been modified, remitted or converted?

Completion

The sanction ends by completion, pardon, amnesty or lapse.

  1. Has the sanction been completed, and how was that recorded?
  2. Did a pardon, amnesty or limitation period end it early?
Record consequences What remains on record after the sanction.

Record and rehabilitation

Entries in records and their removal over time.

Record entry

The sanction is entered in the relevant register with its retention and rehabilitation rules.

  1. In which register is the sanction recorded?
  2. When does the entry become spent or due for removal?

Classifiers Filled

Family
World Models
Category
Society, people and institutions
Entry kind
entity
Navigation path
NAV.SOC.POL.SAN
Domain
SOC.POL.SAN
Industry
Cross-industry
Tags
sanctionsentencesoc.pol.san

What it is Filled

A sanction or sentence is a consequence imposed on a person or organisation by a court or competent authority for a breach of law or rules, such as a prison term, fine, community service, licence suspension or disciplinary measure. The subject is the imposed consequence with its terms and its execution from start to completion; the decision that imposes it, the investigation before it and international restrictive measures against states or listed persons are separate subjects.

In scope

  • Qualified sanction identity, subject and imposing-act references, applicable legal profile and competent roles
  • Terms, component relationships, effect assertions, execution observations, credited progress and contested breach reports
  • Review, variation, completion, residual obligations and governed disclosure/retention references

Out of scope

  • Judgment reasoning, determination of guilt, investigations, appeals and authority/person master lifecycles
  • Imposing, increasing, revoking or enforcing sanctions; detention operations, surveillance, physical restraint, collection and release instructions
  • Pretrial preventive measures, international restrictive-measure lists, private contractual penalties and execution of capital or corporal punishment
  • Executable sentence arithmetic, automated sanction recommendations, eligibility scoring and operational disciplinary or juvenile profiles

Why it exists Filled

Describe one imposed legal consequence, its qualified terms and evidence of its execution lifecycle.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • It is the imposed consequence with an execution lifecycle, separate from the judgment or decision that imposes it.
  • It applies to criminal, administrative and disciplinary breaches alike, each with its own authority.
  • Distinct from enforcement action, which compels compliance rather than imposing a consequence for a past breach.
  • Distinct from international restrictive measures, which target states, entities or listed persons by political decision.

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Impose, increase, reduce or remit a sanction.
  • Record a sanction before the decision is enforceable.
  • Disclose a person's sanction beyond the access rules of the register.
  • Keep a spent record visible after the rehabilitation date.
  • Compute release or completion dates as final without official confirmation.

Only with a human decision

  • Any change to the terms or execution of a sanction.
  • Decisions on early release, conversion or remission.
  • Confirming completion and record removal.

May

  • Track execution status, payments and dates against the imposed terms.
  • Remind the responsible body of upcoming deadlines and review dates.
  • Produce anonymised statistics on sanctions by type and outcome.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Sanctions restrict liberty, property or livelihood, so errors in terms or dates cause direct harm.
  • Records of past sanctions can block rehabilitation long after the sanction ends.
  • Sanctions should be proportionate and applied without discrimination.

Who is affected

  • Sanctioned persons and organisations
  • Victims awaiting restitution
  • Families of sanctioned persons
  • Courts, prisons, probation and collection services

Owners Filled

Steward

The competent authority responsible for executing the sanction, such as a prison, probation or fine collection service.

Roles

Sanction record custodian
Maintain qualified identity, revisions and source reconciliation
Authorized recording officer
Record supported terms and events within explicit authority
Legal profile reviewer
Assess applicability, effect disputes and the need for competent decisions
Records and access officer
Approve purpose-specific views, retention, restriction and disposition
Subject or verified representative
Supply corrections and inspect only the legally permitted view

Master systems

  • Court case management system
  • Criminal records register
  • Prison and probation management system
  • Fine collection system

Links to other meta-models Filled

references

  • WM-POL-021 - Inverse reference to the candidate incoming Judgment CONTAINS Sanction relation. The imposing judgment stays independently mastered; this model does not absorb its reasoning or appeal lifecycle. Other imposing acts are allowed.
  • Imposing act and applicable legal-rule master - Every asserted imposition needs source-act and legal-profile evidence; no concrete neighbor runtime binding is asserted. A missing reference remains unresolved rather than proving no sanction exists.
  • Subject and competent-authority masters - Qualified references to persons, legal entities and authority roles. Identity and competence are not granted by a record link.
  • Implementation case and financial or custody ledger - Authoritative execution events and credit allocations remain in their responsible systems; local reports do not implement enforcement.
  • Review proceeding and criminal-record master - Keep remedy, conviction-record and disclosure lifecycles separate; pin profiles before operational integration.

aligned

  • PROV-O 2013-04-30 - Conceptual attribution and revision alignment only; no implemented mapping or legal-evidence certification.

neighbor

  • WM-POL-021 Judgment - The candidate incoming CONTAINS relation means a judgment may impose a sanction. Preserve the imposing judgment reference without inheriting its full lifecycle. Administrative fines may originate in a different competent act, so a judgment model is not mandatory for every instance.
  • Decision, legal rule, person and competent authority masters - Record qualified references and effect assertions only. Competence, conviction and legal validity are not inferred from a local data link; one subject can have several separately identified sanctions.
  • Execution case, payment ledger and custody or supervision record - Link evidence of implementation without owning enforcement operations or the master financial and custody ledgers. Detention before sentence is a separate matter even if later credited.
  • Criminal record, disclosure and rehabilitation profiles - Completion of this consequence does not automatically erase a conviction, end every obligation or settle disclosure eligibility. External record masters and jurisdiction-specific policies remain separate.

parent

  • WM-POL-021

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • A sanction is identified by the reference of the imposing decision together with the sanction's own record number in the executing authority's system.
  • The sanctioned party resolves to a person or organisation record.

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

A sanction is a legal consequence with terms and dates, not a physical object with measurable properties.

Recognition optional Filled

  • A sanction names the sanctioned party, the imposing decision, the type and the terms.
  • Often confused with the judgment, with an enforcement order or with international restrictive measures.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • Execution can be scheduled, tracked and closed against the imposed terms.
  • Credits such as time served or payments can be applied.
  • Record entries can be retained and removed under rehabilitation rules.

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Wrong release or completion dates leading to unlawful detention or early release.
  • Stale records that block rehabilitation.
  • Disclosure of sanctions to employers or others without a legal basis.

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • Criminal records exchange in the manner of ECRIS between authorities.
  • Notifications from courts to executing authorities.
  • Statistical reporting on sanctions to national statistics offices.

Context of use required Filled

  • Applies in criminal justice, administrative enforcement and professional discipline.
  • Execution is governed by national law and international standards on the treatment of offenders.

Sources Filled

  1. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights - United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights
  2. European Rules on community sanctions and measures with commentary - Council of Europe
  3. Act on Regulatory Offences - OWiG, official English translation - Federal Ministry of Justice and Federal Office of Justice
  4. 2024 Guidelines Manual, Appendix B - Selected sentencing statutes - United States Sentencing Commission
  5. Directive (EU) 2016/680 - Law Enforcement Directive - European Parliament and Council of the European Union
  6. PROV-O: The PROV Ontology - World Wide Web Consortium
  7. Date and Time on the Internet: Timestamps - Internet Engineering Task Force
  8. United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners, the Nelson Mandela Rules (United Nations)
  9. United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for Non-custodial Measures, the Tokyo Rules (United Nations)
  10. European Criminal Records Information System, ECRIS (European Union)

Open questions

  • Verify direct source responses and content, legal versions, controlling translations, treaty applicability and national implementation for each adopting profile.
  • Develop nested schemas and exchange fixtures covering mistaken identity, pre-enforceability records, partial stays, conflicting terms, duplicate credits, alleged breach, correction, completion with residual obligations and lawful erasure.
  • Research specialist disciplinary, juvenile, cross-border and rehabilitation profiles without importing unsupported legal defaults.
  • Restore independent external review before any canonical or publishable-draft promotion.
  • Independent external review is absent; a separate local self-audit cannot substitute for it.
  • Direct HTTP checks are not attempted under the owner-reported sandbox restriction; no local response status or body hash is measured. Current source versions and legal applicability remain held.
  • Nested instance schemas, exchange fixtures, canonical code lists, pinned neighbor bindings and executable conformance are unimplemented.
  • Binding sentence calculations, cumulative credit rules, currency conversion, calendars and operative release decisions are outside scope.
  • Disciplinary, juvenile, cross-border, exceptional penalty, pardon/amnesty and spent-record profiles are incomplete; no universal effect is inferred.

Machine files

Provenance

world-models research · reviewable-draft

Built from: models/wm-pol-022-sanction-sentence/spec.yaml, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/wm-pol-022-sanction-sentence.json