← Back to catalogue
Published

Scholarly Publication

vr.wm-rec-004 · wm-rec-004-scholarly-publication

Describe one scholarly work through evidence-qualified authorship, versions, publication context, citations and status.

World Models Information and virtual systems INF.REC.PUB

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

3 bundles · 4 layers · 6 findings · 12 questions

Work and authorship What the work is and who is responsible for it.

Identity and contributors

Identifiers, title and contributors.

Persistent identity

The identifiers, title and type of the work.

  1. Which persistent identifier, such as a DOI, refers to this work?
  2. Is it a journal article, conference paper, book, chapter, preprint or thesis?

Authorship and roles

Authors, their affiliations and contributions.

  1. Who are the authors, with which affiliations and author identifiers?
  2. Which contribution roles and conflicts of interest are declared?
Venue and review Where and how the work was published.

Publication venue

The journal, proceedings, publisher or repository.

Venue and review process

Where the work appeared and which review it passed.

  1. In which venue and on what date did the work appear?
  2. Was the work peer reviewed, and under which review model?

Versions and status

The version history and current standing.

Version of record

Preprint, accepted manuscript and version of record.

  1. Which version is this record, and which is the version of record?
  2. Has the work been corrected, given an expression of concern or retracted?
Use and access How the work can be read and how it is cited.

Access and citation

Licence, access and citation links.

Licence and access

The licence and access conditions of each version.

  1. Under which licence and access conditions is each version available?
  2. Which funders and grants are acknowledged, and do they set access requirements?

Citation links

Works cited and works citing it.

  1. Which works does it cite, and which data and software does it reference?
  2. Do citing works rely on parts that were later corrected or retracted?

Classifiers Filled

Family
World Models
Category
Information and virtual systems
Entry kind
entity
Navigation path
NAV.INF.REC.PUB
Domain
INF.REC.PUB
Industry
Cross-industry
Tags
scholarlypublicationinf.rec.pub
Also called
N5

What it is Filled

A scholarly publication is a work of research or scholarship made public through a recognized venue, such as a journal article, conference paper, monograph, chapter, preprint or thesis, with its authorship, review, version history and citations. It covers the work and its versions as published, not the underlying dataset, the research project or a general-interest article.

In scope

  • Work identity and classification, descriptive properties and contributor assertions
  • Version-specific release, review and integrity-status evidence
  • Citation and research-output links, scoped rights, access observations and metadata stewardship

Out of scope

  • Research study design, conduct, experimental evidence adjudication and scientific truth certification
  • Person, organization, journal, edition, grant, dataset, software, document-storage and rights-contract master lifecycles
  • Editorial workflow execution, peer-review adjudication, issuing notices, DOI registration, remote dissemination and legal rights clearance
  • General media performance, exhibition, physical copy inventory and bibliometric ranking engines

Why it exists Filled

Describe one scholarly work through evidence-qualified authorship, versions, publication context, citations and status.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • It passes through a scholarly venue with review or moderation, unlike a general web page or press article.
  • One work can exist in several versions, of which only one is the version of record.
  • Corrections and retractions are part of its record and change how it may be relied on.
  • Distinct from the dataset, software or project it reports on, which are separate records linked by citation.

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Cite a retracted work as valid evidence without stating the retraction.
  • Invent references, identifiers, authors or quotations.
  • Attribute authorship by name matching alone when author identifiers disagree.
  • Redistribute full texts beyond what their licence allows.
  • Present a preprint as peer reviewed.

Only with a human decision

  • Deciding on authorship disputes or misconduct allegations.
  • Issuing a correction or retraction.

May

  • Retrieve and cite publications with their persistent identifiers and version.
  • Report corrections, expressions of concern and retractions attached to a work.
  • Link a work to its authors, funders, data and software through identifiers.
  • Summarize open-access works while pointing to the version of record.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Fabricated or misattributed citations damage trust in research and the careers of the people named.
  • Retracted findings keep spreading when downstream users are not told.
  • Access barriers decide who can read and build on publicly funded research.

Who is affected

  • Authors and their institutions
  • Readers, including clinicians and policy makers
  • Publishers and editors
  • Research funders and the public

Owners Filled

Steward

The publisher or repository that holds the version of record answers for its metadata and status, with authors answering for content.

Roles

Metadata custodian
Maintain local identifiers, assertions, provenance and approved mappings
Author or contributor
Provide attributable content and credit declarations without unilateral dispute resolution
Editorial status steward
Supply source-supported review and notice references within documented authority
Rights and access reviewer
Assess version and component permission evidence and recipient scope
Preservation custodian
Own approved retention, hold, disposal and restoration processes
Auditor
Review evidence, qualifiers, mapping losses and unresolved holds

Master systems

  • Publisher content platform
  • Institutional or subject repository
  • DOI registration agency metadata
  • Bibliographic index

Links to other meta-models Filled

references

  • WM-ACT-036 - Local output-to-study reference corresponding to the incoming candidate PRODUCES relation. Zero or many external study masters; no study lifecycle or execution.
  • WM-REC-001 - Separately governed document and metadata-record masters; no file-storage lifecycle duplication.
  • WM-MED-003 - Optional edition or container binding; its exact version and boundary require adoption review.
  • External party, rights, grant, dataset and software masters - Qualified identifiers and subject-specific links only; target lifecycles and authority remain external. Concrete model bindings must be pinned before integration.
  • world-n12-intellectual-property - Copyright and licences govern use of the text.

aligned

  • WM-MED-001 - Conceptual creative-work alignment only. Legacy N5 remains with this neighbor; no mandatory inheritance or performance functions.
  • JATS 1.4 - Article metadata projection only; not a universal book or thesis instance schema.
  • DataCite Metadata Schema 4.6 - Selected descriptive and relationship alignment; registration requirements are confined to that profile.
  • CRediT 2022 - Contribution-role alignment; no automatic authorship or rights decision.
  • JAV RP-8-2026 - Landing-page scope only; detailed vocabulary and migration mapping deferred until full-text review.
  • OAI-PMH 2.0 - Metadata-harvest projection; resource, item and record identities stay distinct.
  • PROV-O 2013-04-30 - Assertion attribution and derivation alignment; no truth or authority certification.

neighbor

  • WM-ACT-036 Research Study - The incoming candidate PRODUCES edge describes an output relationship. A publication can reference zero or many studies; scholarship need not arise from one empirical study. No study methods or operations are owned here.
  • WM-MED-001 Creative Work and legacy N5 - The registry split note leaves legacy N5 with Creative Work. Reconcile its work/version/copy distinctions only; do not inherit performance, distribution-rights execution or historical conformance claims.
  • WM-REC-001 Document / Record - A stored full text and a metadata record have separate masters. The scholarly work is neither its file nor its catalogue entry. Candidate alignment does not imply inheritance.
  • WM-MED-003 Publication / Edition - Journal issues, proceedings and book editions are container references. A scholarly chapter can remain separately identified; this model does not manage print runs or edition production.
  • Review and correction notice records - These have their own identities and access rules and link to an exact reviewed or affected version. Recording a reference does not perform editorial review or issue a notice.

extends

  • wm-rec-001-document-record - A scholarly publication is a document record with authorship, venue and review.

related

  • wm-med-003-publication-edition - Books and monographs also appear as published editions.
  • world-n5-media-and-creative-work - Split off from this legacy card on 2026-10-05; the legacy card keeps the primary subject.

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • A publication is identified by a DOI, with ISBN for books and ISSN for the serial it appears in.
  • Authors are identified by ORCID iDs and institutions by organization identifiers.
  • Bibliographic databases such as PubMed assign their own record identifiers.

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

A scholarly publication is an information work with no physical properties to measure.

Recognition required Filled

  • A publication shows a title, authors, venue, date and usually an identifier, abstract and reference list.
  • Often confused with a preprint of the same work, a conference abstract, a press release or a predatory venue imitating a journal.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • Works can be published, versioned, corrected, retracted, cited and indexed.
  • Metadata can be harvested and linked across publishers, repositories and indexes.

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Spread of retracted or fabricated findings.
  • Fabricated citations generated by automated tools.
  • Licence breach through redistribution of closed texts.

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • DOI metadata from registration agencies.
  • JATS for journal article markup.
  • OAI-PMH for harvesting repository metadata.

Context of use required Filled

  • Used across research, teaching, evidence-based practice and research assessment.
  • Publication ethics follow editorial guidance such as COPE, and funders may set open-access requirements.

Sources Filled

  1. JATS Article Metadata - National Library of Medicine
  2. DataCite Metadata Properties - DataCite
  3. How to implement CRediT - National Information Standards Organization
  4. Journal Article Versions - National Information Standards Organization
  5. Peer review metadata principles - Crossref
  6. Version control, corrections, and retractions - Crossref
  7. DataCite RelatedIdentifier - DataCite
  8. JATS Permissions - National Library of Medicine
  9. Open Archives Initiative Protocol for Metadata Harvesting - Open Archives Initiative
  10. PROV-O: The PROV Ontology - World Wide Web Consortium
  11. Date and Time on the Internet: Timestamps - Internet Engineering Task Force
  12. Introduction to posted content including preprints - Crossref
  13. JATS Reference List - National Library of Medicine
  14. DataCite FundingReference - DataCite
  15. ISO 26324 Information and documentation - Digital object identifier system (ISO)
  16. ANSI/NISO Z39.96 Journal Article Tag Suite (JATS) (NISO)
  17. Core Practices (Committee on Publication Ethics)

Open questions

  • Restore independent external review before canonical or publishable-draft promotion.
  • Run direct source checks outside the sandbox, inspect the full JAV 2026 recommendation and applicable publication-ethics guidance, and verify profile/version applicability.
  • Develop nested schemas and mapping fixtures covering no DOI, anonymous review, multiple version branches, partial dates, uncertain citations, contested notices, component rights and harvest deletion.
  • Review book, thesis and discipline profiles and pin the separately mastered study, document, edition and rights bindings before operational integration.
  • Independent second-provider review is absent under the owner waiver
  • Direct source HTTP verification was not attempted because of the owner-reported sandbox restriction; all statuses remain unmeasured
  • JAV RP-8-2026 full text was not readable through its linked PDF; only official landing scope is admitted
  • Full publication-ethics guidance fetches were denied by the browsing service; no detailed ethics-guideline conformance is claimed
  • Detailed monograph, thesis, multilingual and discipline-specific editorial profiles, legal rights and privacy applicability need qualified review
  • Nested instance schemas, neighbor version pins, citation-metric definitions and executable mappings/fixtures remain incomplete

Machine files

Provenance

world-models research · reviewable-draft

Built from: models/wm-rec-004-scholarly-publication/spec.yaml, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/wm-rec-004-scholarly-publication.json