← Back to catalogue
Published

Decision, claim and evidence

EM-KNW-02 · em-knw-02

Claim, evidence, argument, alternatives and decision, including ADR. Evidence can support multiple assessments without copying.

Enterprise profiles Enterprise subject EnterpriseKNW

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

3 bundles · 3 layers · 5 findings · 10 questions

Claims and evidence What is asserted, by whom, and what supports it.

Claims

Assertions with an author, a context and a status.

Claim

An assertion separated into observation and interpretation.

  1. Who asserts the claim, and in what context?
  2. Is it a direct observation or an interpretation of observations?

Evidence

Artifacts that support or contradict claims, reused by reference.

  1. Which evidence supports or contradicts the claim?
  2. Has any of this evidence been refuted or withdrawn?
Decisions Choices made, the alternatives considered and the reasons.

Decision record

A decision with its authority, options and rationale.

Decision

A dated decision by an accountable person or body.

  1. Who had the authority to make the decision, and when was it made?
  2. Which claims and evidence was the decision based on?

Alternatives

Options considered and the reasons they were rejected.

  1. Which alternatives were considered and why were they rejected?
  2. Under which conditions would a rejected alternative be reconsidered?
Change and impact What happens when evidence is refuted or a decision revoked.

Impact trace

Tracing from refuted evidence to dependent claims and decisions.

Revision of support

Status changes recorded without rewriting history.

  1. Which decisions depend on the refuted evidence?
  2. Has a revoked decision kept its original rationale?

Classifiers Filled

Family
Enterprise profiles
Category
Enterprise subject
Entry kind
subject
Domain
EnterpriseKNW
Industry
Cross-industry
Tags
EM-KNW-02W1subjectClaimEvidenceArtifactArgumentDecisionDecisionAlternative

What it is Filled

Claim, evidence, argument, alternatives and decision, including ADR. Evidence can support multiple assessments without copying.

Why it exists Filled

Claim, evidence, argument, alternatives and decision, including ADR. Evidence can support multiple assessments without copying.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • A claim always has an author and context; citing a document does not make it a fact.
  • Evidence is referenced, not copied, so one artifact can support many assessments.
  • Revoking a decision adds a new record and keeps the original rationale intact.
  • Distinct from the document contour, which records texts rather than assertions and choices.

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Treat a claim as an established fact because it references a document.
  • Rewrite or delete the rationale of a past decision after it is revoked.
  • Record a decision on behalf of someone without the authority to make it.
  • Drop rejected alternatives from the record.

Only with a human decision

  • Making or revoking a decision.
  • Declaring evidence refuted when it is contested.

May

  • Trace which decisions rely on a given piece of evidence.
  • Flag claims that have no evidence or rely on refuted evidence.
  • Draft a decision record with alternatives for a person to complete.
  • Separate observations from interpretations in a summary.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Decisions based on weak evidence can harm people affected by them.
  • Accountability depends on keeping who decided what and why.
  • Evidence can contain personal data that must keep its original access scope.

Who is affected

  • People affected by decisions
  • Decision makers and their reviewers
  • Auditors and regulators

Owners Filled

Steward

The knowledge and records owner who answers for documents, terms and decision logs.

Master systems

  • Document management system
  • Wiki
  • Decision log

Links to other meta-models Filled

neighbor

  • EM-DAT-07
  • EM-KNW-01
  • EM-LEG-01
  • EM-ORG-03
  • EM-PRD-04
  • EM-WRK-02

references

  • WM-KNW-010 - conceptual-candidate
  • WM-REC-010 - conceptual-candidate
  • WM-KNW-007 - conceptual-candidate
  • WM-KNW-008 - conceptual-candidate

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • Identified by a decision or claim identifier in the decision log, with its date and author.

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

Enterprise record contour: physical properties belong to referenced world models.

Recognition optional Filled

  • Marked by an author, a date, a stated position and links to evidence.
  • Often confused with the document in which the claim or decision is written down.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • Impact of refuted evidence can be traced across all dependent decisions.
  • Decision history can be audited including rejected alternatives.

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Circular support where claims cite each other as evidence.
  • Loss of rationale when decisions are superseded.
  • Evidence copied into many places and diverging over time.

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • W3C PROV-O for provenance of claims and evidence.
  • W3C Web Annotation Data Model for linking claims to parts of documents.
  • ISO/IEC/IEEE 42010 for architecture descriptions that record decisions and rationale.

Context of use required Filled

  • Used for architecture decision records, investment cases, audit findings and research notes.
  • Agents use it to cite evidence and to avoid presenting opinion as fact.

Sources Filled

  1. W3C PROV: claims, sources and actions
  2. SKOS: concepts, definitions and mapping
  3. DMS/wiki/ADR practice: document, version, carrier and decision
  4. W3C PROV-DM: The PROV Data Model - Checked live (HTTP 200) on 2026-10-07.
  5. W3C SKOS Simple Knowledge Organization System Reference - Checked live (HTTP 200) on 2026-10-07.
  6. OMG Structured Assurance Case Metamodel (SACM) - Checked live (HTTP 200) on 2026-10-07.
  7. Architectural Decision Records: Maintainer Community Guidance - Checked live (HTTP 200) on 2026-10-07.

Open questions

  • How to distinguish an observation from an interpretation?
  • What happens when evidence is refuted?
  • How to preserve rejected alternatives?
  • Установить границу и решение reuse/extend/new по действующим спецификациям.
  • Подтвердить semantic crosswalk, права и source mastership.
  • Выбрать immutable refs; провести проверки fixtures до заявления о публикационной готовности.

Machine files

Provenance

enterprise research programme · published-partial

Built from: enterprise/models/em-knw-02/brief.json, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/em-knw-02.json

Still in Russian: suggested owner, blocking decisions, vercy candidates. Translate in research/enterprise/i18n/units.en.json.