EM-KNW-02 · Subject model · W1
Decision, claim and evidence
Claim, evidence, argument, alternatives and decision, including ADR. Evidence can support multiple assessments without copying.
Partially published; research continues
Claude: complete-frozen-study-and-audit-with-remediation; Grok: complete-reconciled.
Published results
Research note, in Russian: Canonical/runtime promotion remains governed by the package allocation, identity and dependency holds.
Subject boundary and candidate types
- Claim
- EvidenceArtifact
- Argument
- Decision
- DecisionAlternative
Deep research questions
- How to distinguish an observation from an interpretation?
- What happens when evidence is refuted?
- How to preserve rejected alternatives?
Verifiable invariants
- A claim has an author and a context
- Evidence is not automatically true
- Revoking a decision does not erase the rationale
End-to-end acceptance scenario
Two decisions use the same evidence, which is later refuted: the impact is traceable without rewriting history.
Negative case
A reference to a document turns any claim into an established fact.
Approaches to compare
- W3C PROV: claims, sources and actions
- SKOS: concepts, definitions and mapping
- DMS/wiki/ADR practice: document, version, carrier and decision
Candidates in the live catalogue
- WM-KNW-010 · Decision / Rationale · 0.3.0-research.1 · installable
Semantic fit requires boundary research; a published model does not by itself complete this card. - WM-REC-010 · Decision / Approval Record · 0.3.0-research.1 · installable
Semantic fit requires boundary research; a published model does not by itself complete this card. - WM-KNW-007 · Claim / Proposition · 0.3.0-research.1 · installable
Semantic fit requires boundary research; a published model does not by itself complete this card. - WM-KNW-008 · Evidence / Citation · 0.3.0-research.1 · installable
Semantic fit requires boundary research; a published model does not by itself complete this card.
Result requirements
Every card is executed together with the full research contract: definitions, fields and cardinalities, lifecycle, sources, data mastership, rights, the five object facets, at least eight invariants, positive and negative examples, dependencies, migration and applicability limits.