contradictory
Let an agent explain the contradictory relation in logic, distinguish it from contrariety and other oppositions, identify contradictories of given statements, and support reasoning and teaching.
Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled
4 bundles · 8 layers · 8 findings · 16 questions
Understand The relation.
Definition
Definition.
Definition
Definition.
- What makes two propositions contradictories, and how does this differ from contraries and subcontraries? definition
- Is the logical sense or everyday inconsistency meant? boundary
Square
Square of opposition.
Square
Square.
- How do contradictories appear in the traditional square of opposition? definition
- Which entry fits the square of opposition? action
Apply Using contradictories.
Negate
Forming contradictories.
Negate
Negation.
- What is the contradictory of this statement, including quantified and modal statements? action
- Which errors are common in negation? provenance
Proof
Proof and consistency.
Proof
Proof.
- How are contradictories used in proof by contradiction and in checking consistency? definition
- Which entry fits proof methods? action
Theory Formal treatment.
Formal
Formal logic.
Formal
Formal.
- How is contradiction formalised in classical, intuitionistic and paraconsistent logics? provenance
- Which references are standard? provenance
Philosophy
Philosophy.
Philosophy
Philosophy.
- How have philosophers treated the law of non-contradiction and dialetheism, with positions attributed? provenance
- Which entry fits a specific philosopher? action
Learn Teaching.
Teach
Teaching oppositions.
Teach
Teaching.
- How can contradictories and contraries be taught with examples and diagrams? action
- Which misconceptions arise? provenance
Language
Everyday usage.
Language
Language.
- How is contradictory used in everyday language and law, and how does it differ from the logical sense? definition
- Which entry fits argumentation? action
Classifiers Filled
- Family
- Thing Registry
- Category
- Cross-cutting context
- Entry kind
- noun.relation
- Plane
- XCT
- Domain
- XCT.REL
- Facets: substance
- abstract
- Facets: origin
- conceptual
- Facets: agency
- inert
- Facets: mobility
- not-applicable
- Facets: scale
- not-applicable
- Facets: affordances
- observable
What it is Filled
In logic, the relation between two propositions that cannot both be true and cannot both be false, so that exactly one of them holds, as between a statement and its negation or between the universal affirmative and the particular negative in the traditional square of opposition; contradictories differ from contraries, which cannot both be true but can both be false, and the relation underpins proof by contradiction and consistency checks.
Why it exists Filled
Let an agent explain the contradictory relation in logic, distinguish it from contrariety and other oppositions, identify contradictories of given statements, and support reasoning and teaching.
Distinguishing features Filled
- Opposite truth values
- Negation
- Square of opposition
- Proof use
What robots and AI may and may not do Filled
Must not
- Call two statements contradictory when both could be false.
- Negate a quantified statement incorrectly and present the result as its contradictory.
- Accuse a person of contradicting themselves without showing the two statements conflict.
Only with a human decision
- Using a claimed contradiction to discredit a witness or party in a formal process.
May
- Form the contradictory of a proposition, including quantified statements, correctly.
- Check whether two statements are contradictories or merely contraries.
Moral aspects Filled
- Accusing someone of self-contradiction damages their credibility and should be accurate.
Who is affected
- Students of logic
- People quoted in debates
Owners Filled
Steward
Nobody owns the concept; it is held in common by logic.
Links to other meta-models Filled
parent
- oewn-13805250-n - registry parent class
related
- logical relation - category
- contrary - the neighbouring opposition
- difference - a broader relation
- complementarity - contrast with completion
What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled
Identity and identifiers required Filled
- Vercy registry: vr.tr.contradictory
- Open English WordNet: oewn-13805471-n
Direct properties not applicable Not applicable
Not applicable
Plane XCT: no invented physical properties.
Recognition optional Filled
- Exactly one of two propositions is true
- Statement and negation
- Contraries can both be false
- Not physical; a logical relation.
Capabilities and actions required Filled
- explain the relation
- distinguish from contrariety
- identify contradictories
- support reasoning
Hazards and failure modes required Filled
- Confusing contradictories with contraries
- Misforming negations of quantified statements
- Treating everyday contradiction loosely
Standards and interfaces required Filled
- Conventions of formal logic
- No regulation
Context of use required Filled
- Propositions that cannot share a truth value.
- contradictories in propositional logic
- contradictories in the square of opposition
- contradictory predicates and terms
- contradictions in argument and consistency
Sources Filled
- Open English WordNet 2024, synset oewn-13805471-n - sense and gloss of the concept
- Wiktionary: contradictory - word senses and usage
Open questions
- Should the square of opposition be a separate entry?
- How should logic textbooks be linked?
- How should everyday usage be documented?
Machine files
Provenance
thing registry research (pass 2) · unreviewed
Built from: models/things/publications/thing-contradictory/spec.json