← Back to catalogue
Published

Science System

vr.wm-civ-006 · wm-civ-006-science-system

Institutions, funding, people and infrastructure through which research is produced and governed.

World Models Society, people and institutions SOC.CIV.SCI

Bundle → Layer → Finding → Questions Filled

3 bundles · 4 layers · 6 findings · 13 questions

Actors and infrastructure Who performs, funds and governs research within the system.

Performers and funders

Research performing organisations, funders and policy bodies with their roles.

Actor roles

Each actor is recorded with its role as performer, funder, policy body or infrastructure.

  1. Which organisations perform research in this system, and in which sectors?
  2. Which bodies fund research, and through which instruments?
  3. Which body sets research policy for the system?

Research infrastructures

Shared facilities and data services that the system relies on.

  1. Which research infrastructures are operated within the system, and by whom?
  2. Who may access each infrastructure, and on what terms?
Inputs and outputs What goes into the system and what it produces.

Funding and personnel

Research expenditure and research personnel by sector and field.

Expenditure by sector

Research spending is reported by performing sector and source of funds.

  1. What is the reported research expenditure, by sector and source of funds, for the period?
  2. Which measurement manual does the expenditure figure follow?

Research personnel

Researchers and support staff counted by headcount and full-time equivalent.

  1. How many researchers are counted, in headcount and full-time equivalent?
  2. Which classification of fields and sectors is used for the count?

Outputs

Publications, data, patents and other results attributed to the system.

Attributed outputs

Outputs are attributed to actors through persistent identifiers.

  1. Which identifiers link outputs to researchers and organisations?
  2. Which output types are counted, and which are left out?
Governance and evaluation How the system is steered and assessed.

Policy and assessment

Strategies, funding rules and research assessment exercises.

Assessment practice

The system has stated rules for evaluating researchers and institutions.

  1. Which assessment exercise or criteria apply to institutions in the system?
  2. Does the assessment rely on publication metrics, peer review or both?

Classifiers Filled

Family
World Models
Category
Society, people and institutions
Entry kind
aggregate
Navigation path
NAV.SOC.CIV.SCI
Domain
SOC.CIV.SCI
Industry
Cross-industry
Tags
sciencesystemsoc.civ.sci

What it is Filled

A science system is the organised whole of institutions, people, funding and infrastructure through which a country, region or field produces and governs research. It covers research performers, funders, policy bodies, research infrastructures and the flows of money, people and outputs between them; a single study, publication or institution is a part of it, not the system.

In scope

  • System identity, inclusion rules, observation population and description revisions.
  • Actor roles, mandates, resources, workforce and infrastructure context.
  • Study and collaboration references, output attribution, sharing and policy-level oversight.
  • Assessment context, evidence quality, release and access qualifications.

Out of scope

  • Organization, person, grant, publication and study master lifecycles and operational execution.
  • Research protocols, participant records, funding allocation, recruitment, misconduct adjudication and official-statistics certification.
  • Universal ranking, automatic quality scoring or causal impact claims from bibliometric counts.
  • Detailed hazardous research methods and operational controlled-item guidance.

Why it exists Filled

Institutions, funding, people and infrastructure through which research is produced and governed.

Distinguishing features Filled

  • It is a system of actors and flows, not a single organisation, study or publication.
  • Measured through standard input and output statistics, such as research expenditure and personnel by sector.
  • Distinct from the education system, although universities belong to both.
  • Distinct from a research study, which is one activity performed inside the system.

What robots and AI may and may not do Filled

Must not

  • Rank researchers or institutions on a single metric presented as quality.
  • Attribute outputs to people or organisations without identifier evidence.
  • Mix figures compiled under different manuals without saying so.
  • Disclose unpublished grant applications or peer review content.
  • Present a funding or assessment decision as made when it is only proposed.

Only with a human decision

  • Deciding research funding allocations.
  • Approving the outcome of a research assessment exercise.
  • Publishing official science and technology indicators.

May

  • Compile statistics on research expenditure, personnel and outputs from official sources.
  • Map actors, funders and infrastructures with their persistent identifiers.
  • Report the classification and manual behind each figure.

Moral aspects Filled

  • Assessment rules shape careers and research agendas, so narrow metrics can distort what science is done.
  • Funding concentration can exclude regions, fields and early-career researchers.
  • Research integrity depends on transparent attribution and open access to results.

Who is affected

  • Researchers and research staff
  • Research performing institutions
  • Funders and taxpayers
  • Society that uses research results

Owners Filled

Steward

A national research ministry or statistics office that maintains the official description and indicators of the system.

Roles

System steward
Approve scope and description revisions without claiming ownership of all research actors.
Evidence curator
Record source releases, attribution and measurement qualifications; resolve or flag ambiguity.
Statistical reviewer
Review comparability, aggregation, disclosure risks and breaks in series.
Integrity and access reviewer
Verify oversight routes, confidentiality and release permissions; do not adjudicate misconduct through this model.
Reader or analyst
Use qualified views within purpose limits and preserve uncertainty and holds.

Master systems

  • Current research information system
  • National research statistics database
  • Funder grant management system
  • Organisation identifier registry

Links to other meta-models Filled

references

  • WM-ORG-001 - Candidate reference to organization masters for performer, funder, policy and infrastructure roles; organization lifecycle remains external.
  • WM-PER-001 - Candidate reference for justified researcher identity links; use aggregate data by default and do not copy employment or sensitive personal profiles.
  • WM-ACT-036 - Candidate reference to study identity and portfolio attribution; protocol, execution, participant consent and study findings remain study-owned.
  • WM-ECO-030 - Candidate reference to award or donation records used as evidence of funding; allocation, disbursement and financial control remain externally mastered.
  • WM-REC-004 - Candidate reference to publication versions and correction status; publication content and editorial lifecycle remain external.
  • wm-org-001-organization - Performers, funders and policy bodies are organisations.

aligned

  • CERIF research information profile - Conceptual interchange alignment; choose and pin a release and test mapping losses before an implementation claim.
  • DataCite Metadata Schema 4.6 - Selected output and funding metadata alignment only, with no latest-version or schema-conformance claim.
  • PROV-O - Conceptual provenance mapping for observed entities, transformations and responsible agents; truth assessment remains separate.

neighbor

  • Organization and Person - System membership and role evidence reference separately mastered actors; affiliations can overlap and change without changing system identity.
  • Research Study - The system holds portfolio links and scope assertions, not protocols, experiments, participants or study execution.
  • Grant / Donation - Funding evidence and resource observations do not own award authorization, payment or accounting ledgers.
  • Scholarly Publication and research outputs - The system attributes and counts referenced outputs under stated rules without owning publication revisions or scientific claims.
  • Education and innovation systems - Institutions and training pathways can overlap, but teaching delivery and commercialization are not treated as identical to research performance.
  • Statistical release or information platform - Neither one periodic table nor its storage software is the science system. Stable scope and governance context persist across views and projections.

contains

  • wm-act-036-research-study - Individual studies are activities performed within the system.

related

  • wm-rec-004-scholarly-publication - Publications are a main output counted for the system.

What else AI and robots need to interact with it Filled

Identity and identifiers required Filled

  • A science system is identified by the jurisdiction or field it covers and the reporting period.
  • Its actors are identified by organisation identifiers such as ROR, and researchers by ORCID iDs.

Direct properties not applicable Not applicable

Not applicable

A science system is an institutional arrangement with no physical properties to measure.

Recognition optional Filled

  • A science system is recognised by a set of research performers, funders and policy bodies within a defined scope.
  • Often confused with a single university, a funding agency or a national research strategy.

Capabilities and actions required Filled

  • Research expenditure and personnel can be measured by sector and field.
  • Outputs can be attributed to actors through persistent identifiers.
  • Funding flows can be traced from funder to performer through grant records.

Hazards and failure modes required Filled

  • Metric-driven assessment that rewards volume over quality.
  • Misattribution of outputs through ambiguous names and affiliations.
  • Non-comparable statistics across countries using different definitions.

Standards and interfaces required Filled

  • OECD Frascati Manual definitions for research and development statistics.
  • CERIF data model for current research information systems.
  • ORCID for researchers and ROR for research organisations.

Context of use required Filled

  • Used by ministries, funders and statistics offices that steer and report on research.
  • International comparison relies on shared statistical manuals.

Sources Filled

  1. Frascati Manual 2015: Guidelines for Collecting and Reporting Data on Research and Experimental Development - OECD
  2. Recommendation on Science and Scientific Researchers - UNESCO
  3. Recommendation on Open Science - UNESCO
  4. Main features of CERIF - euroCRIS
  5. DataCite Metadata Schema 4.6 - DataCite
  6. San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment - Declaration on Research Assessment
  7. PROV-O: The PROV Ontology - World Wide Web Consortium
  8. The European Code of Conduct for Research Integrity - ALLEA
  9. Frascati Manual: Guidelines for Collecting and Reporting Data on Research and Experimental Development (OECD)
  10. Common European Research Information Format, CERIF (euroCRIS)
  11. UNESCO Recommendation on Science and Scientific Researchers (UNESCO)

Open questions

  • Run direct source checks outside the sandbox, verify versions and licences, and pin a concrete research-information exchange profile before implementing mappings.
  • Develop nested instance schemas and authorized fixtures covering overlapping systems, transfers, part-time research, output versions, missing data, confidential allegations and lawful disposal.
  • Validate statistical, discipline, language, regional and community-participation profiles with appropriate stakeholders; test comparability and disclosure rules.
  • Restore independent external review before any canonical or publishable-draft promotion.
  • Independent second-provider review is absent; a separate local no-tools self-audit cannot substitute for it.
  • Direct HTTP checks were not attempted under the owner-reported sandbox block; statuses and response hashes are unmeasured. Browser evidence supports selected content only.
  • Complete source currency and implementation version checks remain open. DataCite 4.6 is selected, not asserted latest; CERIF overview has no implementation release pin.
  • Executable nested instance schemas, exact neighbor-version bindings, mappings, population fixtures and conformance tests are not implemented.
  • Jurisdiction-specific official-statistics mandates, funding law, privacy, ethics and retention rules require qualified profile review.
  • Causal societal impact, detailed research quality judgments, mobility models and infrastructure engineering reliability are outside the demonstrated coverage.
  • Discipline, language and regional coverage, informal research, indigenous knowledge protocols and equity measurements need stakeholder validation.

Machine files

Provenance

world-models research · reviewable-draft

Built from: models/wm-civ-006-science-system/spec.yaml, ver-cy/world-models/card-supplements/wm-civ-006-science-system.json